Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Arab-American Detained Repeatedly at Canada Border

Expand Messages
  • World View
    BORDERS SPELL TROUBLE FOR ARAB-AMERICAN NEIL MacFARQUHAR New York times 4/29/07 http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/29/us/29border.html Abe Dabdoub calls the day he
    Message 1 of 1 , Apr 30, 2007
      New York times

      Abe Dabdoub calls the day he was sworn in as an American citizen last
      year the proudest moment of his life, little suspecting that his new
      identity would set off a bureaucratic nightmare at the hands of the
      Department of Homeland Security.

      Most of his family members live in Canada, and on each of Mr.
      Dabdoub's 14 trips to visit them since last August, on his way back
      across the Ambassador Bridge into Michigan, the Customs and Border
      Patrol agents have sent him through a security gantlet, he says.

      He has been fingerprinted 14 times, his body searched 9 times, been
      handcuffed 4 times and isolated in a separate detention room 13 times.
      On the fourth trip, the border patrol agents started subjecting his
      wife to similar scrutiny.

      Two months ago, he sought relief through a new online system that the
      Department of Homeland Security trumpets as a one-stop shop for
      travelers who think they have been wronged, the Traveler Redress
      Inquiry Program, or TRIP. But the problem continues unabated and,
      typical of such cases, no one in the federal government nor his
      elected representatives will tell him why he is being singled out.

      "I've always believed that in America if there is some type of
      injustice going on, that if you make it known to the right people, it
      will get taken care of," said Mr. Dabdoub, 39, who was born in Saudi
      Arabia to Palestinian parents. They moved to Canada when he was 5.

      "This time I've lost faith in the system; it's either indifferent or
      inefficient or both," Mr. Dabdoub, an engineer and manager of a plant
      in Cleveland that provides steel to automobile companies, added, in a
      telephone interview.

      Arab-American and civil rights organizations say experiences like Mr.
      Dabdoub's are common enough that they suspect the federal security
      agency is profiling Arabs and Muslims, an accusation the department

      Various Arab-American organizations and the American Civil Liberties
      Union are holding a conference in Cleveland today to highlight cases
      like Mr. Dabdoub's. They want increased Congressional oversight of the
      terrorist watch list system to insure that the security agency is not
      abusing the basic civil rights of United States citizens at the borders.

      "Their primary job is to make sure the right people are identified on
      those lists," said Kareem Shora, executive director of the
      American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, one of the organizers.
      "If innocent people are being identified in that process, the manner
      with which that can be rectified is very, very limited."

      A Government Accountability Office report issued last September said
      that just 31 individuals whose names were mistakenly on the watch list
      had them taken off in 2005. Thousands of such redress queries have
      been submitted, most of them from people who are misidentified. But
      their names cannot be removed because they are not the person on the
      list, the report said.

      At least two legal cases prompted by border problems are working their
      way through the courts, including one filed in Federal District Court
      in Chicago last year by the A.C.L.U. against the Department of
      Homeland Security and the Federal Bureau of Investigation.

      More recent episodes that provoked concern include one in which border
      agents reportedly Googled the name of an Ohio man and then questioned
      him about a letter to the editor he had written to The Toledo Blade
      regarding events in the Middle East.

      In Chicago, the government is trying to get the A.C.L.U. case
      dismissed on the grounds that such stops are "routine," said Harvey
      Grossman, the legal director for the Illinois branch.

      Documents the court forced the government to release in February
      indicate that the Customs and Border Patrol agency has received more
      than 11,000 queries about border issues since Sept. 11, 2001, he said,
      while Immigration and Customs Enforcement has received 4,855.

      The government maintains that it cannot identify how many of the
      complaints stem from border detentions, which underscores its
      "cavalier attitude about the treatment of citizens," Mr. Grossman said.

      The homeland security response is that its basic job is to identify
      "bad guys," and that this generates some greater inconvenience that
      affects a fraction of the millions of Americans traveling.

      Since the TRIP system was inaugurated in February, it has received 600
      to 800 complaints a week, said Russ Knocke, the spokesman for the
      department, and it takes time to process them through all of the
      federal agencies who can contribute to the terrorism watch list.

      He would not comment on Mr. Dabdoub's case, noting only that the
      department was aware of it, and emphasized that seeking redress was no
      guarantee against extra scrutiny.

      Mr. Dabdoub said no one he contacted in the government helped him.
      After the first incident, on Aug. 6, he wrote his two United States
      senators, George V. Voinovich and Mike DeWine, who was defeated last

      He received a joint form letter saying they would look into the
      problem and get back to him. He never heard from either one again. He
      got no response at all to two letters he sent to Marcy Kaptur, his

      Homeland security officials took five months to answer a first letter,
      and suggested he complain to the border supervisor.

      Drawing a little extra scrutiny because of his Middle Eastern origins
      is one thing, he said, but being singled out on every crossing is
      abusive, and he carefully logs each incident on a spreadsheet. He said
      he faced no problems on his repeated border crossings from 2001 until
      2006, when he lived in the United States as a Canadian with a green
      card, he said.

      Marc Rotenberg, executive director of the Electronic Privacy
      Information Center, a privacy rights group, said, "A big reason that
      these watch list systems don't work is because the agencies are
      allowed to compile all this information that basically goes

      Mr. Rotenberg noted that oversight groups including the White House
      Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board, which issued a report
      this month saying it would review the amount of transparency possible,
      all ignored the Privacy Act.

      For any government agency to say, "We have got something on you but we
      can't tell you what it is, really goes to the heart of what the
      Privacy Act tried to prevent," Mr. Rotenberg said.



      To subscribe to this group, send an email to:


      Need some good karma? Appreciate the service?
      Please consider donating to WVNS today.
      Email ummyakoub@... for instructions.

      To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.