Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Ethiopia & Starbucks' Coffee Dispute

Expand Messages
  • World View
    What s in a name? Plenty, Ethiopia tells Starbucks By Brenda Ryan Nov 9, 2006 http://www.workers.org/2006/world/ethiopia-1116/ How does the free trade pushed
    Message 1 of 1 , Dec 4, 2006
    • 0 Attachment
      What's in a name? Plenty, Ethiopia tells Starbucks
      By Brenda Ryan
      Nov 9, 2006
      http://www.workers.org/2006/world/ethiopia-1116/


      How does the "free trade" pushed by U.S. corporations really work?

      Ethiopian coffee farmers don't make enough in one whole day to buy a
      latte at Starbucks. But the Ethiopian government has a plan to change
      that. It's seeking trademarks on Ethiopia's famous coffee names in
      hopes of getting a larger share of their retail price. The charity
      group Oxfam estimates that the trademarks could bring the Ethiopian
      coffee industry and farmers an additional $88 million per year.

      Starbucks, though, is standing in the way.

      Last year the Ethiopian government filed applications with the U.S.
      Patent and Trademark Office to trademark the Sidamo, Harar and
      Yirgacheffe coffee names. While Ethiopia received a trademark for
      Yirgacheffe in August, the National Coffee Association and Starbucks
      are opposing registration of the other two names.

      "Coffee shops can sell Sidamo and Harar coffees for up to $26 a pound
      because of the beans' specialty status," Tadesse Meskela, head of the
      Oromia Coffee Farmers Cooperative Union, said in an Oct. 26 Oxfam
      press release. "But Ethiopian coffee farmers only earn between 60
      cents to $1.10 for their crop, barely enough to cover the cost of
      production. I think most people would see that as an injustice."

      U.S. corporations are fiercely protective of what they regard as their
      intellectual property. Patents on AIDS drugs have prevented the people
      of Africa from obtaining low-cost versions of the medicines. But when
      it comes to the resources of poor countries, they have a double standard.

      Starbucks is calling on Ethiopia to register the coffee names as
      geographic indicators┬ľnames given to indicate the specific place where
      a food, wine or spirit comes from. The PTO has registered more than
      100 geographic indications, including Darjeeling for tea cultivated in
      Darjeeling, India. Once someone receives a registration, only products
      produced in that region may carry the geographic name.

      Starbucks said in a press release that geographic certification
      systems "are far more effective than registering trademarks for
      geographically descriptive terms, which is actually contrary to
      general trademark law and custom."

      That's not what Starbucks was saying two years ago when it tried to
      trademark one of Ethiopia's coffee names. In 2004 it filed an
      application to register "Shirkina Sun-Dried Sidamo" as a trademark.
      According to PTO's website, the application was abandoned in July. The
      Guardian reported Oct. 26 that the PTO had rejected Ethiopia's
      application because the word "Sidamo" was already in Starbucks'
      application. The article says that once Starbucks' application became
      inactive, the National Coffee Association opposed Ethiopia's
      application at the request of Starbucks. The NCA and Starbucks both
      denied that the firm asked the association to intervene.

      Light Years IP, a non-profit group that seeks to alleviate poverty by
      helping producers in developing countries gain ownership of their
      intellectual property and use it to increase their export income, has
      been helping the Ethiopian government register trademarks for Harar,
      Sidamo and Yirgacheffe.

      While these gourmet coffees are sold at a premium price at stores like
      Starbucks, Ethiopia is exporting them at prices close to those of
      commodity coffee. "Ethiopia receives only around 6 percent of the
      retail price their fine coffees earn in foreign markets," Light Years
      IP says on its Web site. "In comparison, producers of Jamaican Blue
      Mountain Coffee capture 45 percent of their product's retail price."

      Light Years IP says Ethiopia has already been granted trademarks in
      more than 30 countries and plans to license the coffee names to
      individual companies around the world free of charge. Now that's a
      deal you're not likely to see at Starbucks.

      *********************************************************************

      WORLD VIEW NEWS SERVICE

      To subscribe to this group, send an email to:
      wvns-subscribe@yahoogroups.com

      NEWS ARCHIVE IS OPEN TO PUBLIC VIEW
      http://finance.groups.yahoo.com/group/wvns/
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.