Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Tom Hurndall Killer A Bedouin Israeli

Expand Messages
  • World View
    Who put Taysir el-Heyb in charge for killing Tom Hurndall? Date: Mon, 29 Aug 2005 ....Taysir el-Heyb -....is the soldier who was recently sentenced to eight
    Message 1 of 1 , Aug 30, 2005
    • 0 Attachment
      Who put Taysir el-Heyb in charge for killing Tom Hurndall?
      Date: Mon, 29 Aug 2005
      ....Taysir el-Heyb -....is the soldier who was recently sentenced to
      eight years in prison for killing Tom Hurndall, a young Briton active
      in the International Solidarity Movement (ISM) who was shot in the
      head in Rafah when he tried to keep Palestinian children away from an
      IDF post along the Philadelphi route commanded by el-Heyb...

      Who put Taysir el-Heyb in charge?
      By Aryeh Dayan
      http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/618220.html English

      Several weeks ago, two police patrol cars sped into Wadi Hamam, a
      Bedouin village with 1,300 residents on the foot of Mount Arbel, a few
      kilometers north of Tiberias. Moments earlier, several shots had been
      heard and an anonymous caller had notified Tiberias police that the
      shooters were brothers Taysir and Walid el-Heyb, local residents
      serving in the IDF. "Two patrol cars stopped below the balcony and
      five policemen burst into the house shouting, `Where's Taysir? Where's
      Walid?'" relates Naamat el-Heyb, the mother of the two. "I told them
      that Walid's away in the army and asked them if the police didn't know
      that Taysir's been in prison for almost two years."

      This is just one method of intimidation that Wadi Hamam residents have
      been employing against the el-Heyb family. The brothers' enlistment in
      the army did not make the family a target of intimidation;
      approximately 40 percent of the young men in Wadi Hamam, a village
      afflicted by unemployment, neglect and poverty, volunteer for the IDF
      or Border Police. The main factor in turning the villagers against the
      family is the fact that Amira el-Heyb, the 20-year-old sister of
      Taysir (22) and Walid (21), enlisted in the Border Police, becoming
      the first Bedouin woman to serve in a combat position in the security
      forces (villagers were indifferent to the service of four other women
      as secretaries in the police department).

      Amira el-Heyb, currently serving with a Border Police unit in the West
      Bank, broke a deep-seated taboo in the conservative Bedouin culture
      and condemned her family to alienation of and ostracism. The fact that
      both she and her brother Taysir said their enlistments came as a
      result of patriotic-Israeli motivation and not as a result of economic
      necessity, as most enlistees in the village usually do, also played a
      part. "I was born here and this is my country," Amira told a Maariv
      correspondent two years ago, right after her enlistment. "Whoever
      doesn't want to live here should go to Arafat," she said. Her brother
      Taysir often said similar things.

      Why should we enlist?

      Villagers are now gloating over the manner in which Taysir completed
      his military service: Sergeant Taysir el-Heyb - who has in the
      meantime been demoted to private and discharged from the army - is the
      soldier who was recently sentenced to eight years in prison for
      killing Tom Hurndall, a young Briton active in the International
      Solidarity Movement (ISM) who was shot in the head in Rafah when he
      tried to keep Palestinian children away from an IDF post along the
      Philadelphi route commanded by el-Heyb.

      "Before I enlisted in the IDF, many people in the village told me not
      to enlist because the army would ruin my life," el-Heyb told the
      judges at his trial, a moment before his sentence was handed down. "I
      don't regret enlisting, but today those same people are saying that if
      this is what the army did to me, then there really is no reason to

      It is hard to find someone in Wadi Hamam today who will not argue that
      Taysir "was framed" or, according to the more popular version, "The
      army chose him to show the world how much it values human life." "If
      it had been a Jewish soldier," says Mahmoud Wahib, Taysir's uncle, "he
      wouldn't even have gotten a one-year sentence."

      "If the deceased had been a Palestinian and not a Briton," adds Yassin
      el-Heyb, a neighbor and distant relative of Taysir, "no one would have
      been interested in the incident and it's doubtful whether they would
      have even investigated it. The Druze officer who fired an entire
      magazine at a girl in Rafah came out totally clean. Why? Because the
      girl was Palestinian and not British. But in this case, the family of
      the deceased made a fuss in the media, the British government
      submitted protests and Israel decided to prove to the world, at poor
      Taysir's expense, how much are army is concerned about human life.

      "If this is how the army treats a guy like Taysir, " he concludes,
      "who had nothing on his mind other than dreams of a military career
      and circulated in the village and convinced people to enlist, then
      it's clear that no Arab need enlist in the army anymore."

      The decision written by Colonel Nir Aviram, head of the Southern
      Command military tribunal that heard el-Heyb's case, describes his
      serious actions in harsh terms: "While serving as commander of the
      watch tower on the Philadelphi route in Rafah, when he was left alone
      on the shift, on the afternoon of Friday, April 11, 2003," wrote
      Aviram, "Sergeant Taysir fired from a distance, a single, unnecessary
      shot, a criminal shot at an innocent man."

      In a confession made to his military police interrogators, the verdict
      goes on to relate, he said that he decided to shoot at the young man
      wearing the orange vest of the ISM because the members of this
      organization "pissed off" the army and interfered with its operations.
      He did not intend to kill him, he said, only to fire a shot at him
      "that would whistle in his ear" and prompt him to leave the area.

      It was only months after the shooting that he made this admission. On
      that April day, immediately after he realized that the bullet he fired
      did not whistle past the young man's ear, but had hit him in the head,
      "The accused fabricated a sequence of events to cover up his actions
      and distance him from responsibility for the shooting and its

      The decision lists his actions one by one: He phoned his commander and
      reported that armed man was approaching his post, claimed that the
      armed man was refusing to obey his instructions to halt and received
      permission from his commander to fire at the man; several minutes
      later he again phoned his commander, this time to tell him that he had
      hit the man in the head. His commander accepted his version of events,
      did not investigate the matter in depth and rushed to determine that
      Taysir had acted appropriately. Only months later, in the wake of
      international pressure, did the military prosecutor decide to
      investigate the incident again.

      The story of the young Bedouin man, who dreamt of enlisting in the IDF
      in order to be accepted into the Israeli collective and who is now
      ending his military service with a sentence of eight years in jail, is
      an Israeli tragedy that could, perhaps, have been avoided. A review of
      the sequence of events and of the documents accumulated in the court
      case, and a look at el-Heyb's past, personality and social-familial
      background reveals a series of warning signs that sprung up along the
      way to the post on the Philadelphi route where the fatal shot was fired.

      None of these warnings prompted el-Heyb's commanders to ask themselves
      questions as they should have. Attorney Ilan Bombach, a leader of the
      Bar Association who was appointed el-Heyb's defense attorney as part
      of his reserve duty, feels the IDF should have prevented this tragedy.
      The army's main mistake, Bombach told Haaretz, was that it posted
      "such a soldier, with such a history, with such limited abilities and
      with such a background" in a place where soldiers are required to
      "exercise a lot of judgment in extremely tense situations."

      Based on his personal details, which the army was well aware of,
      el-Heyb "was not capable of exercising such judgment and was the last
      person suited for this job," Bombach says. "He came to the army with a
      lot of motivation, but with very few abilities and poor emotional
      resources. Making him a commander of a post on the Philadelphi route
      was like throwing him to the dogs. The army should have understood
      this well before the incident."

      A home without furniture

      Taysir el-Heyb, the oldest of six children, was born in July 1983 and
      lived most of his life in a small, rickety hut with no bathroom. The
      Israel Lands Administration (ILA) recently razed the hut, saying it
      had been built without a permit. His father worked as a day worker in
      agricultural jobs until he became ill, first physically and then
      mentally, and became unable to support the family. His mother worked
      cleaning homes in Moshav Migdal, whose luxurious homes are just a few
      hundred meters away from the Wadi Hamam huts that are on the brink of
      collapsing. A few years ago, she also became ill sick and, like her
      husband, had to stop working.

      Taysir's sister Amira also cleaned homes in Migdal, until her
      enlistment. Since then, her parents' monthly National Insurance
      Institute allowance of NIS 2,500 has been the family's only income.

      A few years ago, before Amira, Walid and Taysir enlisted and before
      the ILA razed the hut where they lived, the family started to build a
      two-story house. In the course of its construction, the parents became
      ill, stopped working and had to halt the construction. The ground
      floor still has exposed concrete walls. On the second floor, where
      they now live, the walls were covered in whitewash, long since peeled,
      the windows are broken and there are hastily improvised electrical
      wires hanging exposed and dangerous. Most of the rooms do not have
      finished floors. Apart from few plastic chairs and an old and empty
      refrigerator, there is no furniture in the house - no beds, no tables
      and no closets.

      The family sleeps on mattresses on the floor and the few clothes they
      have are piled in cardboard boxes. The father, whose illness has cut
      him off from reality and is therefore unaware that his son has been
      sentenced to a lengthy prison term, roams the rooms all day long,
      staring at the walls and windows.

      The three younger children in the family, who are 14, 16 and 18, have
      never been to school. "I never had money to buy them books or
      notebooks," their mother says, adding that the State of Israel's
      welfare authorities have never asked her why her children are not in
      school. Taysir did go to school. "Until seventh grade, he went to the
      school in the village," says Mahmoud Wahib, his uncle, "but it's
      impossible to say that he learned anything there. He never had books
      and he never had supplies. Today he barely knows how to read and write
      in Arabic and he doesn't know how to read and write in Hebrew at all."

      From the age of 13 until he realized his dream of joining the Israel
      Defense Forces, he worked in a metal shop in Tiberias. His enlistment
      was not a given. The psychological tests determined that his skills
      were very close to the lower limit, the cutoff below which potential
      enlistees are not eligible for military service: Colonel Aviram made
      sure to write in his verdict that el-Heyb "was given a
      psycho-technical rating of 10 (on a scale of 10 to 90) and was rated
      43 in the quality group (on a scale of 42 to 65)." Despite these
      figures, the IDF agreed to induct him and to send him to serve as a
      fighter in the desert patrol brigade, known as the Bedouin brigade."

      In his first year of service, which he spent mostly in training camps,
      el-Heyb managed to be absent without leave twice - once for 22 days
      and once for 34 days - and to serve four short terms in military jail
      - one of them for "inserting a cartridge into his gun, cocking it and
      releasing the safety, contrary to orders." Later in the year, he again
      used his weapon contrary to orders, this time while on vacation in
      Wadi Hamam, and was sentenced to 12 days in jail and a three-month
      suspended sentence. In July 2002, when he was already serving in the
      Termite post on the Philadelphi route, he was sentenced to seven
      months in jail for "using a dangerous drug in serious operational

      Despite all this, the army subsequently decided to promote him to the
      rank of sergeant, appoint him commander of the post and post him there
      armed and alone, in a position on the edge of Rafah, facing a large
      civilian population.

      "This whole episode, including the verdict, is a serious indictment of
      the IDF," say Bombach. "In the end the army, which inducted el-Heyb
      into its ranks and did not bother to look after his needs and help him
      resolve his problems, turned him into a scapegoat, so that the
      military establishment as a whole could come out clean in the eyes of
      the world. The prosecutor in the trial told the court that `the whole
      world' was watching the trial. I said in response that it can only be
      hoped that the war of perception that the state of Israel is waging at
      Taysir el-Heyb's expense would not turn his trial into a show trial."

      In his arguments before the court, Bombach stressed that el-Heyb was
      the first soldier to be tried for manslaughter since the outbreak of
      the current intifada and the first since the 1980s to be sent to jail
      for a lengthy term as a result of an intifada-related shooting
      incident. Two weeks ago, Bombach notified the IDF that he intends to
      appeal Taysir's conviction, in order to reopen the entire case.



      To subscribe to this group, send an email to:

    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.