Sentencing of Dr. Aafia Siddique
- The Sentencing of Dr. Aafia Siddiqui...(and a few closing thoughts)
El-Hajj Mauri' Saalakhan: <SSaala@...>
SHAWWAL 1431 A.H. (September 29, 2010)
THE PEACE THRU JUSTICE FOUNDATION
AA: My list-serve indicates that this inadvertently did not go out to some of our groups (for some inexplicable reason); and therefore, because it may be of interest, here it is. If you already received it, pardon the duplication. - MS
Assalaamu Alaikum (Greetings of Peace):
On the morning of Thursday, September 23, 2010, Dr. Aafia Siddiqui was sentenced to 86 years of imprisonment by a federal judge in New York City. The sentence imposed by U.S. District Judge Richard M. Berman came as no surprise to this writer. I expected the sentence to be harsh; that is precisely why in the months leading up to this fateful day, we spoke about the need for a mass mobilization at the courthouse.
After Aafia's unjust conviction in February of this year (following a two week kangaroo court proceeding) we instinctively knew that we needed to send a message to the government, because the die had already been cast in the U.S. Judiciary. Judge Berman would follow a predetermined script which would result in a life sentence for a woman already put through 7 ½ years of pure living hell.
If anything surprised me it was how clumsy and inept Judge Berman appeared to be in following the script. He really exposed much of the corrupting rot within America's judicial system, revealing, in a very profound way, the extent to which America has become a nation of laws without justice!
What follows is a summary of the notes taken by this observer at last Thursday's sentencing.
The Sentencing of Dr. Aafia Siddiqui
Notes from September 23rd
El-Hajj Mauri' Saalakhan
Judge Berman began by walking the court through the accepted facts of the case. He noted, among other things, that it has never been definitively established why Aafia was in Afghanistan in July 2008. As he proceeded to outline the differing points of speculation as to why she may have been there, he failed to even mention the possibility that she may have been kidnapped and taken there! (I found this deliberate omission glaring to say the least!)
Berman spoke about the 2 lbs of sodium cyanide and the documents in English and Urdu outlining U.S. targets, and the means to conduct terrorist attacks, that Aafia was allegedly carrying in the bag that she had with her. (A bag that Aafia testified during the trial was given to her when she was briefly released in Afghanistan, in a severely weakened and disheveled state by her captors, after five years of secret and torturous imprisonment.)
There were a number of issues raised and statements made during the proceeding that generated many more questions for this observer.
According to the government, Aafia twice attempted to escape from Afghan custody; she had incriminating terrorism-related items in her possession, and yet she was permitted to remain unrestrained behind a curtain in a room of a police compound. Why? Does this scenario even make sense from a security standpoint?
Judge Berman made repeated references to Aafia's mental state acknowledging the damage done to her psyche when it suited him to do so; and ignoring the damage done when it didn't. He also noted the frequent security searches that Aafia objected to during the time she was in New York's custody awaiting trial.
The "security searches," as he termed them, were the strip searches (which also included a cavity search) that this woman already in maximum security confinement was made to endure each time she was moved from one point to another for any reason! This treatment alone is severely damaging to the psyche of any modest woman but especially for a hijab observing Muslim woman.
Berman stated that the jury convicted Aafia of all seven counts in the indictment; that Aafia articulated her belief during the trial that Israel was behind the attacks of 9/11; and that one of the employees at the Brooklyn detention center (where she was being held) was conspiring against America. Berman also accused Aafia's oldest son (Ahmed) of making contradictory statements since his release; he noted that Aafia's former husband (Mohamed Amjed Khan) claimed to have seen her on a number of occasions, in passing, during the time of her disappearance; and reiterated the point that there was "insufficient evidence in the record" to determine where she was between 2003-2008. (A process that he, at the government's request no doubt, helped to facilitate.)
Berman asserted that Aafia came into contact with radical elements while in Boston, according to the testimony of a professor whose name I didn't get. He noted how "complicated" the case had been, and referenced an incident during the trial that resulted in his decision to excuse a juror from the case who felt threatened by a conspicuously attired observer in the courtroom - an observer who made threatening and disruptive gestures before being removed by U.S Marshalls.
Many of us in attendance that day felt that this unknown person (who despite his arrest? was never identified in media reports) may have been a plant of the government, whose sole purpose was to sow additional prejudice in the collective mind of the jury against the defendant in the dock. We also felt this way about the theatrics of one of the government's witnesses (a soldier who took the stand during the trial). I believe that may have been Captain Robert Snyder.
The defense attorney, Dawn M. Cardi, began by stating she respectfully disagreed with Judge Berman's recitation of the so-called "facts" surrounding this case. She noted how she had to get top secret clearance a very time consuming and cumbersome process - to be able to have access to certain "top secret" documents; only to later be told, "there is no classified evidence relevant to this case!"
Cardi argued that Aafia suffered from "mental illness" and "diminished capacity" and, according to one of the experts at Carswell, where she spent the first few months of her return to the U.S. receiving medical treatment and psychological evaluations - she was possibly schizophrenic.
She also argued that while the government has repeatedly used Aafia's academic major as an indication of the potential threat she posed to America, Aafia was not a "biologist." Her academic focus, as reflected in the title of her thesis, was on how children learn. She also noted that the jury found Aafia not guilty on "premeditation" (a finding that Judge Berman deliberately chose to ignore).
Cardi also noted the Wiki-leaks reference to Dr. Siddiqui, and that according to these documents, Aafia was reportedly reaching for the gun (M4 rifle) when she was shot! In referencing the judge's assertion that, "There is no question about the jury's verdict," Cardi insisted that there were indeed questions about the verdict. She spoke about the manipulation of fear, and asked for as maximum sentence of 12 years without the enhancements.
The government's closing arguments could be summed up in the words of lead prosecutor, Assistant U.S. Attorney Christopher LaVigne (who stated, in the government's successful pursuit of a Life sentence): "Any fear that was injected in this courtroom came from witnesses like Captain Robert Snyder of the United States army looking down the barrel of a loaded gun and believing he would die This [Aafia's alleged assault on U.S. personnel] was not some random act. On that day the bottom line is, she saw her chance and she took it."
(In my humble opinion, this narrative was successful - despite all of the contradictory material evidence and testimony in Aafia's favor - for three reasons: (a) the way this case was consistently portrayed in the mainstream media; (b) the court's decision to bar certain exculpatory testimony that could have proved Aafia's innocence; (c) and the failure of Aafia's well paid defense team to vigorously put on the type of defense that a political trial of this nature required!)
Aafia's defense kept emphasizing mental illness, and at one point Judge Berman interrupted (and in his own manipulation of this argument) alternately raised doubts about the severity of Aafia's mental state, and then raised doubts about the prospect of Aafia getting any better.
Aafia flatly rejected the mental illness defense, defiantly stating in a strong, clear voice: "I am not paranoid. I am not mentally sick, I disagree with that!
(For the record, while there is no question that serious damage has been done to our sister's psyche, I personally believe Aafia Siddiqui is very, very sane in a morbidly insane world!)
And while Berman spoke of how Aafia consistently failed to cooperate with "authorities" he said nothing about the conditions of confinement which, no doubt, factored into Aafia's failure to "cooperate."
Aafia addresses the court
Aafia began by insisting she was not concerned with her own welfare she is content with the qadr (or will of God), and that she is not being tortured. She did not say she was never tortured; she said she was not being tortured at present.
(This is an important distinction for those of us who have followed this case closely. Who are aware that Aafia was tortured when she was secretly held; and are equally aware that, at minimum, Aafia has been imprisoned in the U.S., for the past two plus years, under conditions that clearly violate our nation's constitutional guarantee against "cruel and unusual punishment.")
Aafia accused someone by the name of Mr. Desmond (I believe) of plotting against the United States. (This may have been a sign of mental unbalance. ALLAH knows best.)
She again referenced the "secret prison(s)" that she had previously been held within; a secret imprisonment that the U.S. government adamantly refuses to acknowledge.
Aafia spoke about terrorists who were masquerading as Hispanics to do America harm, and of how DNA testing can be done to determine the "pedigree" of a person. She also spoke about not being against all Israelis, but that there is an element among them that are blameworthy.
She noted at one point, in a rather light-hearted way, that most of the teeth in her mouth were not her own, because of the beatings she endured while she was secretly held. She also noted how one of her doctors had initially diagnosed Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), but how she was then pressured into saying otherwise i.e. that Aafia was schizophrenic.
Aafia testified to how before being brought to the U.S. - she would regurgitate to the FBI the things that she thought they wanted to hear (a mind "game" she called it), in the belief that by doing so she would be able to get her children back. She passionately emphasized that she is against all wars!
She spoke about a dream she had involving Prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him), and she advised the Taliban to put mercy in their hearts. She referenced [British journalist] Yvonne Ridley's capture and subsequent voluntary conversion. She said in her dream she saw the Prophet enter a room with American soldiers who were captives of war. The Prophet (pbuh) spoke consoling words to them. Her advice to Muslims was to not hate American soldiers.
She also (curiously for this writer) spoke about Israeli-Americans who had her daughter for years and never raped her. When she said this I wondered if this was something she had been told, or was this a conclusion that she had come to as a sort of psychological coping mechanism? (Surely ALLAH know best.)
Moments later Aafia's voice broke and I know that many within the main and overflow courtrooms choked up when she touched briefly upon the anguish experienced by a mother who doesn't know where her children are.
Judge Berman Rules (or so he thinks)
Berman proceeded to outline the reasoning behind the barbaric sentence he was about to impose on Dr. Aafia Siddiqui. At the heart of his thinking was his stated belief that rehabilitation for Aafia was virtually impossible, as he proceeded to impose "enhancements" that would significantly magnify her sentence.
1. He found that the "hate crime enhancement" applied due to the national origin of Aafia's alleged victims (U.S. personnel).
2. He found that the "official victim enhancement" applied because the alleged intended victims were government officials.
3. He found that the "terrorism enhancement" applied because the alleged offense was intended to influence or punish the government. (Keep in mind, Aafia was not officially charged with even one terrorism count in the indictment; and yet she received a terrorism enhancement! Berman feebly argued that the defendant's purpose or intent factors into the equation.)
4. He also found that a "criminal history enhancement" applied in the case. (I'm still trying to figure out his twisted rationalization behind that one.)
5. He also found that an "obstruction of justice enhancement" applied, because Aafia gave (in his view) false testimony during the trial.
6. Berman also found Aafia guilty of "premeditation," based on the claim that when Aafia allegedly fired the M4 rifle at the agents and soldiers in 2008, she screamed, `I want to kill Americans,' and `Death to America!'
Later, in an attempt to make it appear that he was truly wrestling with what would constitute the appropriate sentence for Aafia Siddiqui, he rhetorically asked: Do we sentence concurrently or consecutively?
In truth, Judge Berman exemplified nothing more than soft-spoken, anti-Muslim, pro-prosecution bigotry; bringing to mind (for this observer) one of the caustic assessments that the late NY State Supreme Court Justice Bruce Wright made about some of his fellow jurists on the bench. (As he termed it, "Black Robes, White Justice")
At one point there was a rather embarrassing moment for Judge Berman, when in response to his deliberation over the issue of whether or not Aafia fired the M4 rifle, one of the prosecutors stood up to say the jury did not find that Aafia fired a weapon. The judge than clumsily remarked that he found that she did.
After being hit with what constitutes a mandatory life sentence (86 years), Dr. Aafia Siddiqui was the embodiment of faith and grace. She again partially turned toward the witnesses in the courtroom seated behind her, and counseled the Muslims to not become "emotional."
At one point Aafia addressed the judge's bias at the conclusion of the trial (when he charged, or instructed the empanelled jury before their deliberations). She reminded him of how he had emphasized to the jury that if they found that there was a gun in the room that Aafia potentially had access to, that they had to find her guilty on that particular gun related count.
What came next from a mindset of forgiveness and mercy would contrast sharply with the poor excuse for a "judge," who presumed to preside over her fate. Aafia was clearly in a much better place, mentally and spiritually, than were Judge Richard Berman and his fellow persecutors, in that regrettable process euphemistically called a court of law.
After Berman pronounced his sentence a woman in the main courtroom, whose voice sounded familiar, hollered SHAME! SHAME! SHAME ON THIS COURT! (I was in an overflow courtroom observing the proceedings over a video monitor) I later learned that the voice which was then threatened with removal from the court belonged to a committed friend, Sara Flounders, of the International Action Center.
Judge Berman than expressed his concern about the absence of any psychological road map to assist Aafia in her mental health challenges; while already having expressed his belief that: (a) she really wasn't that mentally unbalanced; and (b) even if she was, therapy "would be to no avail" anyway, because she had not been cooperative in the past. (As noted earlier, Judge Berman alternately accepted or rejected the prospect of mental illness whenever it suited his argument of the moment.)
What then followed became a lesson in faith and spiritual perseverance. Aafia counseled those present, and those who would get the news later, not to be angry at anyone involved in this case not even the judge!
"This will shock the Muslims: I love America too I love the whole world..."
"I am one person, and the Prophet Mohammed, peace be upon him, forgave all of his personal enemies. Forgive everybody in my case, please the world is full of injustices and also forgive Judge Berman."
"I don't want any bloodshed I want peace and to end all wars."
This was some of the nasiha (sincerely-given advice/counsel) offered by this incredible, long suffering, 38 year old Muslim woman. Berman feebly expressed his gratitude for Aafia's good wishes, and said he wished all defendants were like her. (Can you believe this?)
When Judge Berman informed the defendant of her right to appeal his verdict, Aafia's response was: "I appeal to God and he hears me."
A few closing thoughts of a personal nature
I left that federal courthouse in New York feeling like I had witnessed something truly amazing. Despite the anticipated outcome, I felt inspired, and that a tremendous weight had been lifted off of me. It had just recently come to my attention earlier that same week how much anger I had been carrying around inside of me because of this case (and many others like it).
That same week, following a reception with Iranian President Ahmedinejad in New York City, I verbally lashed out at a Muslim leader for his attempt at defending the indefensible. In that moment I felt nothing but contempt for him and others like him. ("Leaders" and "Major Muslim Organizations" who failed to issue even ONE press release, or community alert, in defense and support of a sister like Aafia Siddiqui!)
In those moments, outside of that New York City hotel, all of the disappointments and indignities that I had been forced to endure over the past two years (over this one case) came flooding over me; the doors that were slammed in my face; the back-biting emanating from "leaders" within my own community; the very personal assaults that were made through my family; the sleepless nights; the moments of isolation; the counterproductive efforts that were sometimes made to prevent much needed material resource from coming our way all of this came flooding over me as this brother attempted to make me feel as if I was wrong for putting undo pressure on him and his fellow play it safe procrastinators.
I was so angry that I felt like I could hit this brother; and then after we left each other I felt ill (I felt physically ill) for a while. As I calmed down, I remembered something that President Ahmedinejad had said in his closing remarks to all of the Muslim leaders assembled before him: "They want to make us angry Don't let them make you angry."
It was then, in that moment, that I realized it wasn't just Aafia Siddiqui. The anger I felt, the anger that had reached a boiling point with this particular case (involving this sister), is an anger that had been building up for years! It was a volcanic accumulation of all of the pain, tears, anger and frustration that I had been exposed to (and often-times experienced) going back many years. Aafia Siddiqui's case was simply the one that brought it all to a head.
Later that night, I pleaded with Almighty ALLAH (The Beneficent, The Merciful) to help me deal with that internalized rage and a few days later, ALLAH answered my prayer.
Thank you Aafia.
I've been informed that an estimated one million supporters came out for the demonstration below (in Karachi), and not one person was injured or killed! Al-hamdullilah (All praise belongs to ALLAH)! - MS
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-south-asia-11431179 [GREAT PHOTO]
KARACHI: A massive rally organised by the Muttahida Qaumi Movement on Tuesday unanimously demanded that the United States government set aside the 86-year jail term of Dr Aafia Siddiqui and release her forthwith.
A very large number of people, including women and children, took part in the rally held on M.A. Jinnah Road to express solidarity with Dr Aafia Siddiqui. Besides representatives of other political and religious parties, Dr Fauzia Siddiqui, Aafia's elder sister, also attended the rally.
Strict security arrangements were made by the police and Rangers and the main M.A. Jinnah Road was closed to vehicular traffic. Workers of the MQM manned the inside security of the venue, spreading from the Quaid-i-Azam's mausoleum to Tibet Centre.
MQM workers took out small rallies from their respective areas which later converged at the main venue, the Quaid's mausoleum.
Before MQM chief Altaf Hussain started his address, the deputy convener of the MQM coordination committee, Dr Farooq Sattar, read out the resolutions, which were unanimously approved by the participants.
The participants of the rally replied in the affirmative when Dr Sattar asked them whether this massive rally condemned in the strongest terms the sentencing of Dr Aafia Siddiqui by a US court.
Declaring Aafia "the daughter of the nation", the participants shouted huge slogans in her favour and rejected the sentence handed down to her on what they said fake and concocted charges.
Through another resolution, the rally demanded the US government and President Barack Obama set aside Dr Aafia's jail term and release her immediately.
Earlier, speaking at the rally, Dr Sattar said the entire nation and the MQM were with Dr Aafia Siddiqui. "MQM rallies being held at 60 places in the country reflect that the 170 million people of Pakistan demand Dr Aafia's release."
Speaking on the occasion, Dr Fauzia Siddiqui thanked MQM chief Altaf Hussain and the people of Karachi for extending their all-out support to her sister. "This huge rally proves that the whole nation wants Dr Aafia released."
While the MQM chief, Altaf Hussain, spoke at length on Dr Aafia's Siddiqui's issue and certain other matters in his speech, he also asked the people of Karachi to make their city a peaceful place and protect one another's life and property.
He said people belonging to different ethnicities were living in Karachi and it was their collective duty to protect every citizen irrespective of his or her ethnicity.
He appealed to people belonging to every sect to respect each other's views and show unity among themselves to foil all conspiracies.
WORLD VIEW NEWS SERVICE
To subscribe to this group, send an email to:
To leave this list, send an email to:
NEWS ARCHIVE IS OPEN TO PUBLIC VIEW
Please consider contributing to WVNS today.
Email ummyakoub@... !