Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Messages List

124784

Re: Convoys intrinsic ASW & Planes with 0 Air-to-Naval value in the

I think chrome is a bit harsh.   I think the differences in the games we've played are not so much significant in a single battle but the overall effect. 
Robert Chiasson
Aug 27
#124784
 
124783

Re: Vichy redux

No just careless.... On Wed, Aug 26, 2015 at 12:25 AM, Paul Davis pd35226@...
William Popovich
Aug 25
#124783
 
124782

Re: Vichy redux

probably a slowplayer too. From: "William Popovich popovichwilliam@... [wifdiscussion]" To:
Paul Davis
Aug 25
#124782
 
124781

Re: Vichy redux

I'm a slow reader. On Tue, Aug 25, 2015 at 5:11 AM, uk_cags@... [wifdiscussion]
William Popovich
Aug 25
#124781
 
124780

Re: Vichy redux

OK, I get that, but whatever answer comes back, it needs to deal with the clarification to published RaW as well as the latest and next samizdat versions.  As
Terry O'Leary
Aug 25
#124780
 
124779

Re: Vichy redux

You can request that all you want (and many on the rules list are as impatient as you are) but it is Harry's decision entirely and if he chooses not to publish
William Popovich
Aug 25
#124779
 
124778

Re: Vichy redux

Exactly right.  As you say Bill, I started this thread to clarify the published RAW, not to debate future rules.  The issue with liberation seems to be that
Terry O'Leary
Aug 25
#124778
 
124777

Re: Vichy redux

Only 8.89 Bill? Were up to 99.99 in Bristol !
kierhardie
Aug 25
#124777
 
124776

Re: Vichy redux

Yes. You may either conquer Vichy France (completely or incompletely) or any of its minors, or liberate France with Paris, destroying Vichy France. On Mon, Aug
William Popovich
Aug 24
#124776
 
124775

Re: Vichy redux

If the allies liberate occupied France VF ceases to exist. See LOC 17.5. This is different from the allies conquering VF. Steve Sent from my iPhone
Steve Balk
Aug 24
#124775
 
124774

Re: Vichy redux

8.93 now. Steve Sent from my iPhone
Steve Balk
Aug 24
#124774
 
124773

Re: Vichy redux

This is what happens when we miss a WiFCon I guess! ^_^ From: "William Popovich popovichwilliam@... [wifdiscussion]" To:
Andrew Baird
Aug 24
#124773
 
124772

Re: Vichy redux

Raw 9? Are we up to that yet? My last was 8.89..... On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 10:22 PM, Paul Davis pd35226@...
William Popovich
Aug 24
#124772
 
124771

Re: Vichy redux

 concerning ADG raw 9 regular WIF vichy rules.  My read of the new Vichy rules at wifcon concerning allied collapse of Vichy France requires the capture of
Paul Davis
Aug 24
#124771
 
124770

Re: Vichy redux

We really can't discuss the new rules in depth here and certainly not the design of them yet.... though some discussion inevitably leaks in, the thread was for
William Popovich
Aug 24
#124770
 
View First Topic Go to View Last Topic
Loading 1 - 15 of total 124,784 messages