A.r.s Week in Review - 9/29/2002
Week in Review Volume 7, Issue 26
9/29/2002 by Rod Keller [rkeller@...]
Alt.religion.scientology Week in Review summarizes the most significant
postings from the Usenet group Alt.religion.scientology for the preceding
week for the benefit of those who can't follow the group as closely as
they'd like. Out of thousands of postings, I attempt to include news of
significant events, new affidavits, court rulings, new contributors,
whatever. I hope you find it useful. Like many readers of a.r.s, I have a
kill file. So please take into consideration that I may not have seen some
of the most significant postings.
The articles in A.r.s Week in Review are brief summaries of articles
posted to the newsgroup. They include message IDs for the original
articles, and many have a URL to get more information. You may be able to
find the original article, depending on how long your site stores articles
in the newsgroup before expiring them.
Free A.r.s Week in Review subscriptions are available. Subscriptions are
also available on Yahoo. Email firstname.lastname@example.org or
see http://groups.yahoo.com/group/weekinreview. PDA channel available at
Week in Review is archived at:
> RitalinThe Washington Post reported on September 25th that Lisa Marie Presley and
other Scientology witnesses were scheduled to speak before the U.S. House
Government Reform Committee.
"Cause Celebs Lisa Marie Presley and Sarah Ferguson, the Duchess of York,
have been traipsing the halls of the Congress lobbying for their
respective pet projects. Presley, a Scientologist and mother of two will
be testifying today before Indiana Republican Rep. Dan Burton's House
Government Reform Committee on the evils of hyperactivity medication for
Advocacy group CHADD issued a warning prior to the hearing.
"On Thursday, September 26, the House Committee on Government Reform,
chaired by Representative Dan Burton (R-IN), will conduct a hearing
entitled 'Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorders - Are Children Being
"Four of the five witnesses - invited by Representative Burton - are
reported to be spokespersons for or persons associated with the Citizens
Commission on Human Rights (CCHR), an affiliate established 1969 by the
Church of Scientology. CHADD is concerned that four witnesses associated
with the hearing share the belief that AD/HD is a lie and a fraud. They
include: Lisa Marie Presley, Bruce Wiseman, Dr. Mary Ann Block, Patricia
"As further context of the CCHR's philosophy, among their publications
currently in circulation are 'Psychiatry Betraying Families: The Hoax of
ADD/ADHD and Other Learning Disabilities,' 'Psychiatry: Shattering Your
World with Drugs,' and 'The Hoax of Learning and Behavior Disorders.' The
fifth witness, invited at Mr. Burton's request, is Mr. Neil Bush, the
President's brother, whose son was incorrectly diagnosed with AD/HD.
"Through the efforts of Representative Henry Waxman (D-CA) to ensure a
balanced discussion, Clarke Ross, CEO of CHADD and Dr. David Fassler,
representing the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
(AACAP) and the American Psychiatric Association (APA), also have been
asked to testify. It is expected that the National Institute of Mental
Health will also send a witness."
From Reuters on September 26th:
"Adversaries in the debate over widespread prescribing of Ritalin and
other stimulants to children squared off on Capitol Hill Thursday, only to
arouse the ire of lawmakers who accused them of serving as fronts for the
drug industry and religious groups.
"A parade of witnesses came before the House Government Reform Committee
to tell lawmakers why an estimated 3 million to 6 million US children are
currently on Ritalin and other drugs used to treat attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Committee members voiced concern that
doctors are too quick to diagnose the disorder and prescribe strong drugs
in children who may not actually have a mental disorder.
"Chief among the drug's detractors were three witnesses from the Citizen's
Commission on Human Rights, an anti-psychiatry watchdog group. The
organization points out that scientists have no reliable way of confirming
a child's ADHD diagnosis and that teachers have too much sway in
convincing doctors to medicate unruly children.
"But Rep. Constance Morella (R-MD) pointed out that the Citizen's
Commission for Human Rights (CCHR) was founded in 1969 by the Church of
Scientology, a religious group known both for attracting celebrity members
and for vehement opposition to all of psychiatry. Morella read a statement
from Jan Eastgate, the organization's international president, which calls
psychiatry a 'malignant disease' that 'threatens society and ultimately
mankind.' Wiseman said he agreed with that view, and said that his group
maintains an independent tax status from the Church of Scientology.
"Morella also challenged Dr. Mary Ann Block, a board member who treats
ADHD children with nutritional and anti-allergy interventions instead of
drugs. Block accused psychiatrists and other doctors of prescribing ADHD
drugs for financial gain. 'You'd probably gain a little bit too if people
were scared away from psychiatric drugs,' Morella said.
"The committee also heard from Children and Adults with Attention
Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (CHADD), a group that defends the
widespread treatment of children and adults diagnosed with the disorder.
The CEO of CHADD, E. Clarke Ross, told the committee that ADHD may be
underdiagnosed in US kids and that more doctors should be aware of
professional guidelines governing the identification and treatment of the
"Psychiatrist David Fassler told lawmakers that drug treatment 'can be
extremely helpful' in treating ADHD but that 'medication alone is rarely
the appropriate treatment.' 'Medication should only be used as part of a
comprehensive treatment plan that will usually include individual therapy,
family support and counseling and work with the schools,' said Fassler,
who heads the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry."
From People Daily News on September 27th:
Lisa Marie Presley testified before the House Committee on Government
Reform in Washington, D.C., to discuss what she considers an alarming
trend to medicate children for mental disorders ranging from
Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) to bipolar disorder.
"'I have personally seen the effects of overmedicated children and it
terrifies me, especially having two kids of my own,' said Presley, the
international spokesperson for Citizens' Commission on Human Rights, a
psychiatric watchdog group founded in 1969 by the Church of Scientology
(of which she is a member). The group advocates legislation that would bar
schools from forcing parents to medicate their children for ADHD and
"Presley says her passion for this subject is purely personal. 'I became
involved with this whole issue because of a little 4-year-old boy, a
friend of the family, who has suffered from being overmedicated,' says
"Presley told PEOPLE that her first time testifying before Congress left
her 'a nervous wreck, ' but, she said, 'I was really impressed with the
whole system and with the knowledge of the congress people. They really
knew their stuff and asked good questions and got right to the point. Even
the people who were on the other side of the issue seemed to understand
where we were coming from.'"
> Laura's LawA Los Angeles Times editorial on September 28 urged the Governor or
California to sign a law that would allow judges to order outpatient
treatment for mentally ill people. Scientology has protested against the
law outside the state capitol.
"By press time Friday night, Gov. Gray Davis still had not signed 'Laura's
law,' an important bill that would let judges order outpatient treatment
for seriously mentally ill people who can't fathom the gravity of their
condition. The deadline is midnight Monday.
"Davis had pledged to do everything in his power to protect Californians
from crime, so supporters of the bill had expected him to embrace the
measure. It would enable some of California's most vulnerable people,
including many who live on sidewalks or alongside freeways, to get help
before they harm themselves or others. But opponents of the legislation
have grown particularly vocal in recent weeks.
"Two weeks ago, for instance, a subgroup of the Church of Scientology,
which opposes virtually all psychiatric treatments, sponsored a rally at
the Capitol against Laura's law - named after a 19-year-old killed by a
man whose mental illness had been left untreated.
"Gov. Davis often says his top priorities are protecting law and order.
Few bills now before him would do that job better than AB 1421."
> CCHRThe Canton Journal reported on September 27th that Scientology has
protested outside a hospital in Ohio to bring attention to alleged
mistreatment of patients.
"Members of a Church of Scientology group, called the Citizens Commission
on Human Rights, recently protested outside the Judge Rotenberg Center in
Canton. Their banners read 'Patients Tortured Here' at the Rte. 138
center. One protester was Lorraine Barritz of Canton. She said she was
deeply disturbed to find that anyone in the community would be subjected
to such forms of cruelty and abuse. The protesters did not go inside or
have contact with the center staff.
"The Judge Rotenberg Center treats severely troubled clients. It uses
physical punishments with some patients. But it does not physical abuse
clients, he says.
"A Scientology official named Christopher Garrison, director of the
Citizens Commission on Human Rights, brought up the case of a woman who
died in the center in 1990. She died of a perforated ulcer. Garrison
charged a connection with a therapy she was undergoing. Garrison lists a
number of treatments his group dislikes. 'Tortures,' said one of the
banners, 'that have been used - electric shock, restraints, food
deprivation, foul odors, helmet static (noise), and physical abuse' are
all questionable therapies.
"In recent years the Center has been investigated and cleared in the death
of a different inmate. A court suit ended up clearing the Center and its
people in that case. Answering the more recent protests was the Center
director, Dr. Matthew Israel. He is the center's founder, too. Some of the
therapies on the Scientology list are actually legitimate treatments, he
notes. Physical restraints are part of some therapies. So is food used as
a reward, within limits. He calls the type of therapy used at the center
is known as 'aversive therapy' which involves behavioral modification.
Absolutely, Israel said no client had ever been physically abused at the
"What the Scientology group plans to do is uncertain. It asks those who
have violations of human rights to expose them through the Commission on
Human Rights, which is a private organization. Yes, the Judge Rotenberg
Center sometimes uses tough methods. And those can shock the uninitiated
lay person. Cases of physical abuse have to be guarded against at all
times in this sort of treatment. But the Scientologists have no case to
> Keith HensonKeith Henson reported that Scientologists have interfered with efforts to
sell his home in Palo Alto, California by posing as interested real estate
"Santa Clara County Association of REALTORS
1525 Meridian Ave., Suite 101
San Jose, CA 95125
"Dear Board Members:
"I would like to call your attention to seriously unethical behavior on
the part of one of your members. I have been subject to attack from the
Scientology cult for years. After the cult corrupted the DA's office and
the courts in Hemet, CA I was sentenced to a year in jail for picketing
Scientology's desert compound over the two women they killed in the spring
and summer of 2000. As a result of death threats against me on the
Internet I elected to become a refugee in Canada rather than be subjected
to a Scientology controlled jail. This past summer my wife and I decided
to sell our Palo Alto home so she could join me in exile.
"We tried to sell it through an agent, but the ones we talked to were in
fear for their children should they take such a commission. So we sold it
ourselves, only to find it had an illegal lien in it. That involved the
bankruptcy court. The court ruled that my creditor (Scientology) should be
given a chance to get a better price. An agent contacted by our lawyer
told my wife that we had received fair market and that the existing sale
should go through since he could do no better. This would not give the
cult the delay they were seeking so they turned to a Scientologist, Pat
Dulleck who is a real estate agent as well as an agent for Scientology.
"I believe that bringing in an agent who is well known for infiltrating
and trying to destroy a Scientology splinter group and is a close
associate of Darlene Bright who works against me for the cult's dirty
tricks department is a violation of the court's orders. Pat Dulleck and
two others who we believe are also be Scientologists inspected my home
without identifying themselves as members of the cult that considers me an
enemy and will do anything under their 'fair game' policy to destroy me."
> NarcononNarconon International Newsletter reported that a meeting of its Science
Advisory Board was held at its Oklahoma location.
"Narconon International held a major meeting of its Science Advisory Board
at Narconon Arrowhead. Attendees including Alfonzo Paredes, M.D., David
Root, M.D., Shelley Beckmann, Ph.D., and Jim Barnes. Also there were
friends and consultants of Narconon Arrowhead, Sandy MacNabb and Emery
Johnson, M.D. (former Asst. Surgeon General U.S.), as well as Arrowhead's
new Medical Director, Dr. Gerald Wooten.
"Other attendees who shared their experiences and knowledge were Dr.
Allan Sosin from Narconon Southern California, the distinguished Dr.
Schoenthaler from California State University Stanislaus, and with Michael
Phillips from Utah, who is completing a long-term outcome study on the
reduction of crime in juveniles who've completed the New Life Center
"The day's discussions focused on how to design and complete a series of
objective evaluations and studies of the Narconon program's effectiveness.
Dr. David Root was elected the board's new Chairman; he has authored
several papers on L. Ron Hubbard's sauna detoxification program and
addressed international conferences. Finally, we were all honored to have
a special guest, 54-year veteran Oklahoma State Senator Gene Stipe, who
praised Narconon staff for their decades of care and help for addicts who
too many have rejected as hopeless."
The McAlester News-Capital & Democrat reported on September 24th that
Narconon celebrated the first anniversary of the new facility in Oklahoma.
"In 2000, the Association for Better Living and Education purchased the
former Arrowhead Lodge from the Choctaw Nation for $1.9 million and began
renovating it into a treatment center that officially opened for business
in August of that year. The program moved to the Arrowhead facility from
Chilloco, where it had been since 1989.
"Since its opening, Narconon Arrowhead has had numerous graduates finish a
treatment course at the center, according to Gary Smith, executive
director. In fact, 99 received certificates of completion during a
graduation ceremony Friday night. Luke Catton, president of Narconon
Arrowhead, called the anniversary a 'milestone,' since in one year the
facility had gone from 'opening to being nearly filled to capacity.'
"As the ceremony began, persons carrying flags representing 49 of the 50
United States and 15 foreign countries gathered at the front of a large
tent while those assembled joined to sing 'God Bless America.' State Rep.
Ray Miller, D-Whitefield, who attended the graduation Friday as well as
Saturday's anniversary ceremony, said, 'It was most touching, or heart
rending, I don't know the exact words to use, listening to addicts who
have broken the downward spiral of addiction.'"
> Protest SummaryKeith Henson reported a protest at the Toronto Scientology org on
"The unknown picketer and I put in a late afternoon picket at the Toronto
org Sat from about 5:40 to 6:40. As usual I was across the street (which
actually results in a lot more flyers being handed out). The Unknown
picketed in front of the org where 20 scns inside were rapidly reduced to
"We gave out flyers at a faster rate than usual, 200 for me. I was giving
out the Parsonage flyers and again a number of people said they would call
and complain about a non-religion, non-charity getting a tax break on an 8
story office building."
> Priscilla PresleyThe New York Daily News reported on September 26th that Priscilla Presley
thinks that her Husband Elvis would have been a Scientologist if he were
"'I wish that he knew what Scientology was before he died,' the King's
ex-wife told us Tuesday night at a CD-release party for 'Elvis 30 #1 Hits'
at the Hard Rock Cafe. Like her daughter, Lisa Marie, Priscilla has long
been a member of the controversial church. And she's convinced that it
could have 'helped Elvis a lot' as he fought an addiction to prescription
> Internet ArchiveCNET News reported on September 24th that Scientology has removed archives
of certain web sites that are critical of Scientology.
"Buckling under pressure from the Church of Scientology, the Internet
Archive has removed a church critic's Web site from its system. The
Internet Archive, a site that preserves snapshots of old Web pages and
bills itself as 'a library of Internet sites and other cultural artifacts
in digital form,' no longer contains links to archival pages of Xenu.net.
Instead, surfers are pointed to a page telling them the site was taken
down 'per the request of the site owner.'
"However, Xenu.net operator Andreas Heldal-Lund said he never made any
such request. Heldal-Lund, a Norwegian businessman and longtime church
critic, said he's eager for people to read archived pages of his site.
'I'm the author, and I never asked that it be removed,' he said. 'I
believe what's happening in this case is important history.'
"A representative of the Internet Archive said the organization, which is
run mostly by volunteers, took the pages down after lawyers for the Church
of Scientology 'asserted ownership of materials visible through' the site.
He said the group replaced the links with a generic error message about
"However, the organization removed not only Xenu.net pages containing
excerpts from Church of Scientology documents, but also the entire
Xenu.net site, which contains pages crafted entirely by Heldal-Lund."
The Internet Archive issued a statement defending its actions.
"The Internet Archive archives data that is publicly available to provide
services, such as the Wayback Machine, that are useful to researchers,
historians and scholars. While we endeavor to provide as a complete a
record of the Web as possible, we are a small, non-profit, largely
volunteer organization with limited resources.
"Lawyers for the Church of Scientology contacted the Internet Archive,
asserted ownership of materials visible through the Wayback Machine, and
those materials have been removed from the Wayback Machine."