WVN #229: Selectmen clash
- Town elections are two months away and politically charged
clashes are already adding hostility to Board of Selectmen
At Tuesday night's meeting Selectman Alan Reiss, who is
running for re-election on a no-override platform, presented an
alternative to the preliminary plan for budget cuts should an April
property tax override fail. Over the remaining 45 minutes of the
meeting three of his colleagues seemed increasingly
peremptory, chilly and impolite. An observer could disagree with
those characterizations, but nobody would call the discussion
Just as in 2006, when another override was in the works, the
preliminary list of budget reductions threatens to cut emergency
services in Cochituate. If the list remains unchanged, once again
voters will be told: Approve an override or expect to wait longer
when you call 911. The override is currently estimated at about
$2.3 million; services that would be cut from the Council on
Aging and the police and fire departments total $279,000.
(Senior services make up $24,000 of that total.)
Reiss pointed out a budget-trimming decision in the same
range as the proposed health/safety cuts. Faced with declining
enrollment, the School Committee had just adopted a plan
expected to save $250,000 or more. Under the "2-1/2 school"
plan, half of either Loker or Happy Hollow would be shut down
and used for all kindergarten classes. (Schools have a separate
budget and account for about 70 percent of town costs.)
Just as in 2006, Reiss urged the Board to give top priority to
public safety and the elderly. Other departments might therefore
have to absorb the cuts. Residents could face delays when
paying a tax bill, for example, or getting a building permit, and
library hours could be reduced. Reiss quoted from the
Massachusetts handbook for selectmen which he said
mandates special attention to safety and emergency services.
And just as in 2006, Reiss' colleagues professed devotion to the
infirm and elderly but called Reiss' idea "simplistic," "divisive,"
harmful to other citizens who routinely use park, recreation,
education, health and other services. Chairman Bill Whitney,
Michael Tichnor and Joe Nolan strongly support an override.
Reiss' motion to give priority to the areas he favors was
defeated 3-1, with one abstention.
(NOTE: The Finance Committee will hold a public hearing at the
Town Building at 7 p.m. on Monday, Feb. 4 to discuss the Fiscal
2009 budget. Taxpayers may have ideas beyond the scope of
the FinCom's list of reductions in case of an override failure. Are
there other places to save money?)
A FIRST-IN-STATE POLICY?
After the unfriendly budget discussion the board turned to what
might seem a tempest in a teapot that nevertheless occupies a
notable part of the selectmen's recent attention: a policy on using
laptops during meetings.
Why laptops? Since he was elected in 2005, Reiss has
consistently used a laptop at meetings. Other selectmen haven't,
nor have they seemed to pay any particular attention to Reiss'
use of it. Some members of other Wayland boards use them, for
taking notes and perhaps other reasons you can easily imagine.
Online resources are a handy way to consult a map, a law, a
relevant document, a dictionary.
Reiss' laptop became controversial when he opened an email
involving the proposed Verizon cable TV contract, a matter on
which he is the Board's representative. Other selectmen
objected and ordered Town Administrator Fred Turkington to
draft a policy for selectmen's use of laptops and other devices
with Internet access.
When the proposed policy came up for action Tuesday night,
Chairman Whitney repeatedly interrupted when Reiss offered a
revision. Nolan also tried to silence Reiss, who nevertheless
went on to describe his research showing that there was no
evidence that any town in Massachusetts has a policy on using
laptops during meetings. In fact, he said, some towns
encourage their use to increase efficiency.
When consulted, the Middlesex County district attorney's office
had advised that the only possible legal issue involved potential
violations of the state Open Meeting Law, which gives the public
access to any document discussed during an open meeting.
There were two choices, Reiss said: "Park your weapons at the
door," or trust one another. The second option didn't appear to
be in the cards.
Reiss noted that in the past Whitney had asked him to go online
during meetings to get sports scores.
By this time Whitney, Nolan and Tichnor were visibly impatient.
Selectman Doug Leard offered a compromise motion to discard
the proposed 18-paragraph written policy and simply adopt a
consensus that the Internet wouldn't be used in illegal or
inappropriate ways. Tichnor offered an amendment to make the
consensus a "policy." Reiss seconded both motions.
Tichnor said he'd support the motion but stated for the record
that he believes it "is very inappropriate" to do Internet searches
during meetings, whether on town business or not. This
apparently puts him in opposition to the practice of some board
members in Wayland and other towns. When Reiss responded
that for 33 months he has done useful searches that improved
the Board's efficiency, Whitney curtly broke in. Moments after a
quick, unanimous vote the meeting was adjourned.
The selectmen didn't discuss the use of electronic devices by
The policy decrees that except for "urgent communication"
selectmen won't open electronic communications relating to
town business before them. Presumably they'll still be able to
ask Reiss for sports updates.
-- Michael Short
To be sure you continue to receive WVN newsletters optimally
and in your inbox (instead of bulk or junk folders) it may help to
add to your address book or safe sender list:
Thank you for reading this WVN newsletter. Please forward it to
your friends and neighbors in Wayland. If they want to receive
their own copy, they can send an email to
waylandvoters@... and they will be signed up for the
listserv. Or, they can sign themselves up by sending a blank
Click reply and send after receiving an e-mail confirming the
Wayland Voters Network
Michael Short, Editor