Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

WVN Newsletter #189: Wells endangered?

Expand Messages
  • waylandvoters1
    Dear Wayland Voter, The Conservation Commission continues its methodical hearing this week into the potential impact of artificial turf, which raises wider
    Message 1 of 1 , Oct 31, 2006
      Dear Wayland Voter,

      The Conservation Commission continues its methodical
      hearing this week into the potential impact of artificial turf, which
      raises wider questions about the future of Wayland's water
      supply. And the Board of Selectmen replaces a widely respected
      member of the Community Preservation Committee with a
      choice likely to be seen as political.


      The Conservation Commission, which among other things is
      charged with protecting Wayland's water supply aquifers,
      continues its hearing on Thursday Nov. 2. (See
      www.wayland.ma.us for the meeting agenda.)

      When the Wayland Boosters began raising money to replace
      grass at the high school football field with 40,000 ground-up
      truck tires mixed with sand, it's unlikely that they anticipated the
      probing questions and research that followed. This kind of
      artificial surface has become very popular in recent years. (The
      New England Patriots, for example, may use it to replace their
      grass field.) Statistics on athlete safety are well established, and
      proponents say a new field will save money and water.

      But environmentalists counter that, unlike other artificial fields
      such as those at Lincoln-Sudbury High School, Wayland's
      would drain into the municipal water supply and potentially
      threaten an adjacent national wildlife refuge and the federally
      protected Sudbury River.

      At an Oct. 19 segment of the hearing the ConCom heard from
      Gale Associates, the turf consultant hired by the Boosters. Gale
      introduced statistics on overall usage of the material but was still
      completing requested tests and couldn't identify other
      installations with precisely the same environmental

      Two residents, an engineer and a former Wayland hazardous
      waste official, pointed to research in the U.S. and elsewhere
      suggesting that there could be problems. One of them made a
      rough estimate that if the new field increased parking by 25
      percent, the drainage from the field and the parking lot could
      make more than 40 percent of the town's water supply unusable.

      The field would drain through a pipe ending near the Happy
      Hollow wells; salt and petroleum runoff from the adjacent
      parking lot could be a major influence. No plan has been
      presented to address the problem as part of the
      field installation.

      This points to a more comprehensive question. These wells,
      unlike Wayland's other wells, are above allowable limits of
      sodium. Water reaching households combines all sources, so
      the total sodium level is manageable for now. If it is even
      thinkable that the Happy Hollow wells could be damaged beyond
      economical recovery, voters and their elected and appointed
      officials might want to look carefully at how the town is managing
      a resource that may be more vulnerable than they imagined.

      The state Department of Environmental Protection lists as
      "inappropriate activities" in the protected Zone 1 nearest the
      wells "Portions of the high school parking lot and overnight bus

      Responding to earlier WVN newsletters, some readers asked
      what would happen if Wayland's water system failed. The only
      other feasible source is the Massachusetts Water Resources
      Authority, which supplies Boston and many other communities.
      One Wayland water commissioner made a rough guess that
      MWRA water could cost four times what residents now pay.
      According to the Boston Globe, a Boston MWRA bill is nearly
      $1,000 annually for a family of four using 90,000 gallons.

      People tend to take water for granted, at least until it tastes
      terrible, turns brown or stops altogether -- all of which have
      occurred in recent years in Wayland. Some 230 years ago,
      Adam Smith pondered why diamonds, which people don't need
      at all, are expensive while water, absolutely essential, always
      seems to be cheap. Wayland charges low rates but still
      produces a surplus designed to pay for capital expenses as the
      system ages. The Finance Committee recently raided that
      surplus, over Water Commission objections, to ease budget
      problems. Voters may ask whether Wayland is doing enough
      long-range thinking about a valuable resource.

      At the Oct. 19 hearing, ConCom member Andy Irwin called
      attention to the need to take a comprehensive view of the the
      entire local watershed, a complex, interconnected system.

      Water Commission Chairman Joel Goodmonson told the
      hearing that in his opinion there was no problem with the tire
      crumb surface. He acknowledged that salt is a different problem.
      The Water Commission can't stop the project. The ConCom can.

      When the Water Commission met on Oct. 30, two of the three
      members said they opposed artificial turf at the site. The
      commission has no approval role and didn't take a formal vote.

      The Boosters argue that even if the field is used 272 days a year
      as planned, there won't be a large increase in cars using the
      parking lot. But they also say that the idea is to use the field for
      as many activities as possible on as many days as possible. A
      representative of FieldTurf, the manufacturer, noted that in snowy
      weather a field can be plowed and in any case clears by melting
      faster than grass and is usable all year. It would be playable on
      warm days in January, he said.

      Because the existing grass is weak, the field is almost unused
      in the summer. Artificial turf could be used day and night . On
      hottest days, watering can cool the surface.

      The Park and Recreation Department routinely rents town fields.
      The new field could become the most desirable location in town,
      and usage could exceed current expectations.

      Proponents note that Gale has installed hundreds of fields and
      has done much research. "I have to rely on them," said Boosters
      President Craig Foreman. Gale spokesmen apparently weren't
      aware, though, that the proposed drainage has been measured
      at 265 feet from the nearest well, within the zone protected by
      state environmental regulations. Though this particular surfacing
      material hasn't been in service long enough to produce
      ong-term test results, there is noticeable concern in Europe,
      and it is banned in Norway.

      At the Nov. 9 special Town Meeting voters will consider an article
      that would take up to $300,000 from Community Preservation Act
      funds to augment about $700,000 in private donations for the
      installation. The town would be responsible for maintenance.
      Though the Boosters calculate that it would be less expensive
      than maintaining grass, the playing surface would have to be
      replaced after 10-12 years at a cost estimated at $400,000.

      --Michael Short


      In a move that could bolster their power but also upset many
      voters, the selectmen appointed former selectman Betsy
      Connolly to the Community Preservation Committee. Critics are
      likely to see it as purely political.

      Connolly fills the vacancy caused by the surprising decision of
      Michael Patterson in July to refuse reappointment. The board
      offered Patterson another term after some delay even though
      selectman Michael Tichnor had said he was "very troubled" by
      Patterson's independent views on legal counsel, which he called
      "an affront to the selectmen."

      Patterson, who has served in Wayland government for many
      years, said he couldn't in good conscience continue without
      appearing to acquiesce in the position of the board majority on
      curbing the committee's independence. He accused the majority
      of lacking decorum and creating a hostile atmosphere.

      With Connolly, the board should have no worries about
      independent views.

      Before the 4-1 vote on Oct. 23, the selectmen interviewed
      Connolly and the other candidate, former Planning Board
      member Becky Regan. Though everybody praised both
      candidates, voters who had followed the Planning Board's
      tortuous path toward a vote to build a shopping/housing complex
      at the former Raytheon property might have guessed the winning
      candidate. Regan had spoken up often for the planners' duty to
      serve the town's long-term interests, while some selectmen
      appeared to view her board as an obstruction.

      In her interview Regan emphasized the need to maintain
      Wayland's open spaces and to keep enough Community
      Preservation money on hand to save appropriate parcels from

      Connolly spoke of the the Community Preservation Act account --
      about $3.7 million -- as a significant source of opportunities to
      use "unencumbered funds."

      "I'm eager to be the board's representative," Connolly said.

      When Tichnor moved to appoint her, he described her as
      "representative and appointee." The CPC consists of two
      members appointed by the Board of Selectmen and five
      appointed by other boards. Like many town bodies, the CPC was
      intended to exercise a certain measure of independence.
      Regan served on the CPC as the the Planning Board appointee.

      The selectmen and Connolly left little doubt that she is likely to
      be a reliable vote for whatever the board majority is pushing.
      Patterson disagreed with the board's support for using $300,000
      in preservation funds to help pay for artificial turf at the high
      school football field. State lawyers consulted by the CPC
      questioned the legality of the proposal.

      Connolly has many supporters who commend her advocacy of
      the town center project and recent tax overrides. Critics point to
      her record of violating the Open Meeting Law, forming a
      controversial political action committee that was dissolved only
      when it was declared illegal, ignoring dissenting views, and as
      board chairman sometimes acting individually beyond the
      mandate of her position. She dropped out of a 2005 race for
      re-election after one term and became a founder of

      The four selectmen who voted for Connolly no doubt pleased
      the Connolly constituency. Many voters would have seen Regan
      as a step toward greater collaboration and consensus. Only
      Selectman Alan Reiss supported Regan, citing her experience
      on the CPC and elsewhere and her expertise in affordable
      housing, one of the CPC's mandates.

      --Michael Short

      TECHNICAL REMINDER: Some readers using AOL report that
      the previous WVN newsletter didn't reach them. Whether you are
      an AOL customer or not, we recommend following the advice at
      the bottom of each newsletter to enter WVN addresses in your
      list of valid senders. ISP spam filters change over time. In case
      of further difficulties, please get in touch with us. Thanks.
      To be sure you continue to receive WVN newsletters optimally
      and in your inbox (instead of bulk or junk folders) it may help to
      add to your address book or safe sender list
      <mailto:waylandvoters@...> ,
      <mailto:waylandvoters1@...> and
      <mailto:waylandvoters4@...> .
      Thank you for reading this WVN newsletter. Please forward it to
      your friends and neighbors in Wayland. If they want to receive
      their own copy, they can send an email to
      waylandvoters@... and
      they will be signed up for the listserv. Or, they can sign
      themselves up by sending a blank email to:
      waylandvotersnetwork-subscribe@yahoogroups.com. Click reply
      and send after receiving an e-mail confirming the subscription.

      Wayland Voters Network
      Michael Short, Editor
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.