Re: [videoblogging] Slow HD editing
- On Tue, Nov 3, 2009 at 8:00 PM, Rupert <rupert@...> wrote:
>I'm using Streamclip right now to convert my MPEG2 output to MP4.
> Before you make any more drastic decisions about buying new hardware,
> I recommend you download the trial version of Sony Vegas and see how
> that copes. I don't think that much of Corel software generally -
> whereas Vegas is a more respected piece of software, and thus might be
> better at handling your clips.
> Alternatively, can't you just shoot in SD? Or transcode your clips to
> SD using MPEGStreamclip?
After the install hassles (I had to uninstall Quicktime and install a
special version), it's only 18% complete after 10 minutes, so looks
like it's going to take 50 minutes to convert my final video, crazy!
I'll give Vegas demo a try.
> I don't want to sound like a stuck record,No, not much reason really.
> but is there any good reason you need to publish your videos in HD?
But like I said, Youtube now supports and recommends 1280x720, and my
new cam supports it easily, so seems a shame not to use the highest
quality available, if anything for the sake of posterity.
- This is the way we used to work on AVID. Then we had a blissful 10
year interim period with FCP SD editing where you got to cut the
actual clips at original resolution, even if you were doing an online
afterwards. Guess it'll take a while again before the processing
power catches up with the raw hi-res video files generated by top-end
cameras. Then just as we all start cutting those files at original
resolution in real time, everything will switch to 3D IMAX :)
On 12-Nov-09, at 8:20 PM, Pete Prodoehl wrote:
> From what I know of RED workflow, you work on smaller proxy files, and
> then with the final rendering, the hi-res versions are used. This
> editing *much* faster, as we've just learned...
> Here's some related info on FCP and proxy editing:
> Jay dedman wrote:
> > YOU CAN edit MP4 files directly on ordinary hardware!
> >> I can film my blog in HD 1280x720 30fps MP4 on my Xacti HD1010 and
> >> copy the MP4 files directly to my drive and drop straight into the
> >> timeline in VS Pro X2 and trim and edit without any conversion or
> >> other messing around. Then just hit the output option which renders
> >> MPEG2 really quickly, and then I convert to MP4 using whatever
> >> standalone program.
> > congrats on finding that solution. I wonder if this trick extends to
> > other editing programs. Ive never seen "smart proxy" on FCP.
> > Jay
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]