Re: [videoblogging] Re: Plugin for Video Comments
- I would imagine you would see the threaded conversation all on one page.
(Maybe including the whole message... or with links to the messages.)
Charles Iliya Krempeaux, B.Sc.
Vlog Razor... Vlogging News... http://vlograzor.com/
On Feb 1, 2008 8:25 AM, Jay dedman <jay.dedman@...> wrote:
> > it's not necessary that comments be posted directly TO the comment box
> > on a blog post. I personally feel that the best potential of all is
> > to track and display the back and forth BETWEEN blogs /vlogs using
> > permalink tracking.
> > Joe vlogs --> Mary vlogs about Joe's post linking directly to Joe's
> > vlog post --> Joe responds on his vlog linking to Mary's post.
> > Then via various third party systems and track-back mechanisms this
> > conversation becomes visible... trackable... and even RSS
> > subscribe-able... sort of like a tag meme... but much more natural.
> > All that's MISSING from this equation is the tracker to make this
> > dialogue that's already happening visible.
> Hmmmm.....so are you saying we need some service to do track these
> tell me how it works from a user's perspective.
> how does a tracker help me follow conversations across different sites?
> 917 371 6790
> Professional: http://ryanishungry.com
> Personal: http://momentshowing.net
> Photos: http://flickr.com/photos/jaydedman/
> Twitter: http://twitter.com/jaydedman
> RSS: http://tinyurl.com/yqgdt9
Regarding semantic markup... Indeed.
That's why i made mention of XFN earlier to imply that taking the same
concepts of people relations through semantics (my profiles and
friends profiles and discovering connections), the same should be
applied to the conversations being had among these people.
If you are posting a response to another post (barring
trackback/pingback/linkback), making use of semantic markup can build
the graph that can be mapped out and presented logically. a simple
rel or rev with url to the permalink and/or media file along with
other sensible extensions is how this thing should sprout
I've thought a little on what structure can be applied. When thinking
about media pooling, such as the Semanal video pool.... its not truly
about commenting, replying and responding. its about contributing and
But a contributed video to Semanal can also be a response to another
video. So it might make sense to focus on multiple methods and means
to interconnecting media and people in ways that can be trailed via
web services and plugins to common platforms such as WP, Drupal etc.
As far as output... how it all would look and feel. that's maybe a
bit moot in the beginning stages because once the groundwork is in
place, then developers and designers can have infinite ways to present
the relationships and content. I think MIke pointed that out earleir
in this thread or somewhere. It's all challenging and definately the
look and feel discussion is important and should be happening
concurrently... with people doing mockups and prototypes. But some
level of samepageism needs to be set.