Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

1200Re: the "Badly Written" rule

Expand Messages
  • Mike Dean
    Oct 3, 2003
    • 0 Attachment
      In reply to Bruce,

      The PSYCHOPATH house rules actually do state that the GM should be
      informed of deliberate misorders, and that badly written orders
      where the meaning is clear WILL be interpretted as such. So if you
      order F Bul-Con when you have an army, and you don't state that it
      is an intentional misorder, the GM should simply move your army!

      Of course, this means that it is obvious to the other players that
      you deliberately misordered. But so it goes....

      I still reiterate - why do you need a human GM if you are going to
      be so dogmatic about how people should submit orders and that their
      abbreviations should be absolutely correctly spelt or they misorder.
      If that's your view - go play on the JUDGES! A bit of pragmatism is
      called for here and I will always maintain that a good GM will show
      pragmatism when it comes to interpretting orders.

      On psychopath, and I am sure it MUST be true of Dip2000 and other
      sites too - we have a number of players whose first language is NOT
      English. This means that I have often seen orders which instead of
      putting the usual abbreviation for a province on the board clearly
      put something which is an abbreviation of the province name in the
      language of the person submitting the order. What is any reasonably
      minded GM supposed to do in those circumstances?

      IF we follow Malcolm's view - they should be misordered - and hey,
      guess what? The player thinks SOD THAT for a lark, NMRs, anarchies
      and never returns! Well that isn't going to happen when I'm GMing,
      and I hope wouldn't happen on psychopath at all.

      Ah well. I think I will have to agree to disagree on this one. But
      one thing is for sure - I won't change my pragmatic style of GMing
      to be so dogmatic that I discourage players from participating on



      --- In ukpbm@yahoogroups.com, Ben & Linley Goodale
      <ben_goodale@c...> wrote:
      > I'm inclined to agree.
      > Misorders are actually an important part of the game.
      > A proactive GM can always query them with a player.
      > ----- Original Message -----
      > From: Malcolm Cornelius
      > To: ukpbm@yahoogroups.com
      > Sent: Friday, October 03, 2003 2:59 PM
      > Subject: Re: [ukpbm] Re: the "Badly Written" rule
      > on 02/10/03 21:27, Bruce Edwards at kactusjak@t... wrote:
      > > The point I would like to make is the situation where the
      player is
      > > deliberately trying to mislead his neighbours!
      > > Taking Mike's example - if I ordered F Bul > Con when it was
      actually an army,
      > > I would probably be rather put out if the Army was moved when
      my intention was
      > > to pretend to Austria or Russia that I was pulling back!
      > > Maybe if GMs were to stipulate that mis-orders would be
      corrected - if the
      > > intent was fairly obvious - unless the player stated it was
      > >
      > > So if I was to order:
      > > F Bul > Con
      > > Mike would move my Army but if I ordered:
      > > F Bul > Con (deliberate misorder)
      > > then Mike would see my intention is to deceive - and not a
      mistake in writing
      > > the order!!
      > >
      > > I think it would be good if GMs were to point out errors to
      > > especially new players! You can't learn from your mistakes if
      you don't know
      > > what mistakes you made!!!
      > >
      > I don't think the GM should do ANYTHING except enact the orders
      as written
      > by the player.
      > If the player makes a mistake, so be it, unlucky, play better.
      > They should be an adjudicator and not have any other role.
      > F(Bul) - Con when it is an army should fail.
      > Bul - Con should succeed unless the house rules require that the
      type of
      > piece be correctly named.
      > --
      > Best wishes
      > Malcolm Cornelius
      > MSN Messenger - malc_c@c... ICQ - 47738640
      > Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
      > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of
      > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
    • Show all 18 messages in this topic