Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Fwd = Scientists Keep Searching For A Signal From Mars Polar Lander

Expand Messages
  • Frits Westra
    Forwarded by: fwestra@hetnet.nl Originally from: baalke@jpl.nasa.gov Original Subject: Scientists Keep Searching For A Signal From Mars Polar Lander
    Message 1 of 1 , Feb 3, 2000
      Forwarded by: fwestra@...
      Originally from: baalke@...
      Original Subject: Scientists Keep Searching For A Signal From Mars Polar Lander
      Original Date: Wed, 2 Feb 2000 17:52:36 -0800 (PST)

      ========================== Forwarded message begins ======================

      Stanford University

      Dawn Levy, News Service
      (650) 725-1944; e-mail dawnlevy@...

      Mary Hardin, NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory
      (818) 354-0344; e-mail mhardin@...

      February 1, 2000

      Scientists keep searching for a signal from Mars Polar Lander
      By Dawn Levy

      Mars Polar Lander, phone home. That was the command researchers issued
      thrice last week from NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) in Pasadena,
      Calif. But scientists at the Earth receiving station in Stanford, Calif.,
      detected no response from the lander, which had fallen silent Dec. 3 just
      as it was about to enter the Martian atmosphere. This week scientists
      will continue to study the data collected at the "Dish" radio telescope in
      hopes that sophisticated computer analysis will locate a signal among all
      the background noise.

      Mission officials stress that the recent try is a long shot, and the process
      of data analysis and confirmation will not yield immediate results.
      Scientists at Stanford and JPL will continue their sophisticated analysis
      of the data. In the meantime, commands issued from NASA's Deep Space
      Network on Feb. 1 and 2 will tell the lander to reset its clock and send a
      signal to Earth on Friday, Feb. 4. The international scientific community
      has offered to help confirm any signals. Scientists at radio telescopes in
      the Netherlands, England and Italy will be listening for a reply, as will
      scientists at Stanford if they can get time on the Dish, which is booked
      for another research project.

      All this effort was spawned by a faint signal detected by the Dish on Jan.
      4. "It was the radio-frequency equivalent of a whistle," says Ivan Linscott,
      a senior research associate at Stanford's Space, Telecommunications and
      Radioscience Laboratory. Akin to the single, narrow tone that accompanies
      television broadcast tests, the whistle was at the ultra-high frequency
      (UHF) of 401.5 megahertz -- the right place to indicate a possible
      communication from the lander.

      Just as the pitch of a train whistle drops as the locomotive approaches,
      the characteristics of the space whistle changed. "The pitch actually
      had a little curvature to it, and it was that characteristic that got our
      attention," Linscott says. Some of the changes in the space whistle came
      from the Doppler Effect created through the rotation of Mars and the
      Earth. A much larger effect, however, was produced when temperature-
      sensitive crystals in the lander's transmitter warmed up, creating a
      frequency profile that fell, then rose, in a characteristic way, Linscott

      Even though Linscott says scientists are "still hopeful," the search has
      been frustrating. "It's like having a loved one missing in action," says
      JPL research scientist John Callas. "You've given up hope, and then
      there's been a report of a siting and your hopes are raised. Emotionally
      it's a little bit tough. I think in reality the chances are small, but we
      want to make sure. We have a responsibility to be sure, and that's why
      we're here."

      Detecting a signal, even if one is there, is no easy feat. Space is noisy.
      "UHF frequencies are a pretty busy place up here," says Linscott. "But
      we still manage to find quiet places, or at least moments in those quiet
      places, to listen."

      The transmitter on the lander has a broadcast power of about 14 watts,
      says Callas. For comparison, the beacon on the Mars Global Surveyor,
      which is currently in orbit 380 kilometers (228 miles) above the
      surface of the Red Planet, is weaker -- only 1 watt. Boding poorly for
      the mission is the fact that this week the sensitive Dish detected the
      weaker signal from the surveyor, but not the stronger signal from the

      But the main problem is the weakness of the signal. And signals weaken
      as they traverse the roughly 300 million kilometers (about 180 million
      miles) from Mars to Earth. "We expect a signal hitting the Dish to be
      something of the order of one billionth of a billionth of a milliwatt
      [one-thousandth of a watt] of power," says Callas. "It's extremely tiny.
      This is equivalent to listening to a cell phone from Mars."

      More possible woes

      Scientists may no longer know the exact configuration of the lander,
      since NASA has sent many commands to exercise different aspects after
      losing contact with the spacecraft. Also, it is possible that the lander
      may have been "asleep" when some of the commands were sent. If this
      were the case, it would be responsive only after it completed a complex
      "waking-up" process.

      To help them face these considerable technical challenges, the
      researchers have a powerful tool on their side: the exquisitely
      sensitive 150-foot-diameter Dish, which SRI International operates
      and maintains and the U.S. government owns. From a grassy knoll on
      the Stanford campus, the parabolic reflector of this radio telescope
      concentrates electromagnetic waves (radio waves) into an aluminum
      collecting horn built by SRI's Mike Cousins that Linscott calls "the
      jewel in the crown."

      >From there, the signal is fed into a transducer, says Cousins, site manager
      of the Dish. A transducer changes one type of energy into another. Unlike
      the pressure waves of audio, electromagnetic waves from space need to
      be manipulated by transducers and fed into computers before scientists
      can "see" or "hear" the data.

      Using sophisticated software, Linscott and colleagues search among the
      weak signals for narrow, single tones. "Because of the processing that's
      involved in trying to extract them out of the background noise, it's not
      like we put headphones on and hook in like the now-famous image of
      [Jodie] Foster's search in the movie [Contact]," Linscott says. "We don't
      have headphones. What we have are the computers that record the
      signals from the sky, and more computers to try and analyze those."

      Even if scientists are able to eventually detect a signal from the lander,
      will that mean the spacecraft could still serve a useful purpose?

      "If the lander is there and it's talking to us, that tells us a tremendous
      amount of information," Callas says. "It tells us it got to the surface
      of Mars safely or in a reasonably safe configuration and that it's
      generating power, that its computers are operating, that it can hear
      us, and that it can use at least part of its UHF system. That would go
      a long way to understanding what might have gone wrong to put us
      where we are today." A functional UHF system might even allow
      scientists a means of reconfiguring the lander and recovering the
      mission -- a possibility that Callas admits is "extremely optimistic."

      It will take some time to find out the mission's fate. While strong
      signals can be displayed in real time as spectra when they arrive, weak
      signals require lengthier processing. Because of the weakness of the
      signal, it takes "a fair amount of sophistication in the processing of
      this data using computer software to try to extract the signal," Callas
      says. "The human eye is an additional aid to the processing because we
      can make some displays on the computer screen. By looking at them we
      can recognize patterns a lot more readily than a computer algorithm can."

      Support for signal processing came in part from the Bosack Foundation,
      established by Stanford alumni Leonard Bosack and Sandy Lerner,
      founders of Cisco Systems. Mars mission support comes from JPL.
      Lockheed Martin Astronautics Inc. of Denver is the agency's industrial
      partner for development and operation of the spacecraft.

      Stanford graduate students who helped develop the signal-processing
      techniques used include Mitch Oslick, who earned his doctorate and now
      works for Phillips Electronics, and Neza Maslakovic, who will finish her
      doctoral work this summer.


      Photos of the Dish is available at:

      ========================== Forwarded message ends ========================
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.