Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Re: [textualcriticism] 0187--Uncial or Papyrus?

Expand Messages
  • Robert Relyea
    ... Even though it s cataloged as papyrus, it s clearly described as parchment: http://www.rzuser.uni-heidelberg.de/~gv0/Papyri/VHP_I/003/VHP_I_3.html
    Message 1 of 2 , May 22, 2009
    • 0 Attachment
      Daniel wrote:
      In reading Wieland's commentary's description of 0187, I see that it is a 6th-century papyrus fragment of Mark 6:30-42 discovered in Egypt.
      
      But in fact, although catalogued as a papyrus (Pap 1354), it is clearly written on parchment:
      http://www.rzuser.uni-heidelberg.de/~gv0/Papyri/VHP_I/003/VHP_I_3_Rekto_(72).html
      
      Quite a few of the uncials numbered above 0165 seem to have the same problem of being catalogued as a papyrus.
        
      Even though it's cataloged as papyrus, it's clearly described as parchment:

      http://www.rzuser.uni-heidelberg.de/~gv0/Papyri/VHP_I/003/VHP_I_3.html

      Pergament Ev Marc 6
      P.Heid. Inv. G 1354    11,5 x 16,7 cm    VII n.Chr.
      Herkunft: Unbekannt
      Abbildung: VHP I Taf. 58a u. 59a
      Berichtigungen:
      Literatur: G. Cavallo, Ricerche sulla maiuscola biblica, Florenz 1967, 82 mit Anm. 3f.; Nestle-Aland 187; Van Haelst, Catalogue 391; van Haelst, Catalogue, Nr. 391; Nestle-Aland 0187; LDAB 1998.2918.

          * Abbildung des Rekto (72 DPI)
          * Abbildung des Rekto (150 DPI)
          * Abbildung des Verso (72 DPI)
          * Abbildung des Verso (150 DPI)

      Zur Übersicht
      Zum Inhalt von VHP I
      Dieter Hagedorn, Thomas Kruse.

      (and google translation for three of us that haven't yet learned German )

      Parchment Marc Ev 6
      P. Heid. Inv. G 1354 11.5 x 16.7 cm VII AD.
      Origin: Unknown
      Figure: VHP I Taf 58a and 59a
      Corrections:
      Literature: G. Cavallo, Ricerche sulla maiuscola Biblica, Florence 1967, 82 with note 3f.; Nestle-Aland 187; Van Haelen, Catalog 391; van Haelen, Catalog No. 391, Nestle-Aland 0187; LDAB 1998.2918.

           * Image of the recto (72 DPI)
           * Image of the recto (150 DPI)
           * Image of verso (72 DPI)
           * Image of verso (150 DPI)

      For an overview
      Contents of VHP I
      Dieter Hagedorn, Thomas Kruse.

      --------------

      University catalogs don't always distinguish between the actual material a fragment has been written on in their catalogs. Parchment fragments are occasionally dug up along with  papyrus finds and cataloged with those finds (such as the 8 uncial texts which were dug up from the Oxyrhynchus site and carry P. Oxy numbers - 069, 071, 0162, 0163, 0169, 0170, 0206, and 0308).
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.