Wieland Willker wrote: ... What I mean is that Wachtel seems to think that the Byz text developed without thoughtful recensions. His argument is that Byz
Message 1 of 4
, Jan 10, 2005
Wieland Willker wrote:
K. Martin Heide wrote:
> Additionally, Codex W has the majority text only in
> part, Wachtel's stages-theory does not exclude
> larger steps which might be processed by scribes
> during the first decades of the 4th century etc.
What I mean is that Wachtel seems to think that the Byz text developed
without thoughtful recensions. His argument is that Byz variants also
appear in other texttpes. But there the appearance is much more
sporadic. I doubt that such accidental or casual variation can lead
within one century to the full-fledged form represented e.g. in W (Mt,
I am not sure but still think it more likely that SOME FORM OF RECENSION
more likely explains the evidence in the Gospels. What exactly this
recension was I am not sure, but for a Darvinistic development is not
enough time IMHO.
Of course one question is where to draw the line between thoughtful
recension and accidental variation. Perhaps we will meet somewhere in
I agree in part. I don't think there was a "not thoughtful,
Darwinistic" development. It was thoughtful.
Very interesting in this regard is what Tov says about the devlopments
of variants at Qumran, that literary
compositions in the biblical environment (commentaries, Targumim,
citations) served as a ressource
for acceptable variants.
During / after the changes allowed by Constantine,
new bibles were ordered and copied by thousands (cf. the letter of
Const. to Eusebius), and a more smooth and readable,
user-friendly bible was produced for the spread of Christianity. Known
variants which helped to understand the bible
(early church-father citations, commentaries, parallels in the
gospels...) seem to have been allowed to a certain extent,
but controlled (not at random).
(Tov, “The Nature & Background of Harmonizations in
JSOT 31(1985), S.16ff)
Best wishes, MH
Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.