Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Re: [textualcriticism] When did miniscule writing begin?

Expand Messages
  • Jovial
    The reason I raised this question is because I was looking at the Greek writing on the ossuary at the Lost Tomb of Jesus
    Message 1 of 8 , Mar 28, 2007
    View Source
    • 0 Attachment
      The reason I raised this question is because I was looking at the Greek
      writing on the ossuary at the "Lost Tomb of Jesus"
      (http://dsc.discovery.com/convergence/tomb/tomb.html) and when I noticed
      that it was written in miniscule type letters (or slightly pre-miniscule),
      that just didn't fit my normal thinking. I'm more used to looking at Greek
      manuscripts than anything else - I haven't really studied much of Greek
      culture. But after looking at some of the examples the last several days, I
      have to question whether the writing style matches the alleged time period.

      After examining some samples from different time periods I can see how the
      Uncial Greek letters sort of evolved over about 800-1000 years from sloppy
      uncials to taking on a different form to becoming miniscules. But I'd be
      interested in hearing any comments some of you might have on whether you
      think the handwriting fits the time period and whether there are any
      examples that come from the 1st century AD that fit the handwriting style of
      that ossuary well enough to consider it a fit for the time period.



      ----- Original Message -----
      From: Kent Clarke
      To: textualcriticism@yahoogroups.com
      Sent: Tuesday, March 27, 2007 1:50 AM
      Subject: RE: [textualcriticism] When did miniscule writing begin?

      The Old Greek cursive scripts can be really independent looking (I guess
      kind of like any of our handwriting when compared together today), and
      really hard to read. If you have access to the Oxyrhynchus Project site
      (which is free), you can look at many representative examples among the
      documentary papyri.


      Compare, for example, the following:

      P.Oxy.XLVII 3334 (1st C)
      P.Oxy.XXIV 2413 (2nd C)
      P.Oxy.XLVI 3279 (2nd C)
      P.Oxy.L 3560 (2nd C)
      P.Oxy.XL 2905 (3rd C)
      P.Oxy.LXI 4120 (3rd C)
      P.Oxy.XIV 1737 (2nd-3rd C)
      P.Oxy.LXII 4343 (4th C)
      P.Oxy.XVI 1951 (5th C)
      P.Oxy.XVI 1830 (6th C)
      P.Oxy.XIX 2243 (6th C)

      The University of Michigan has a good little online exhibit section, and an
      introduction to papyrology. Check out the brief section that compares
      various scribal hands throughout the years. Its pretty easy to distinguish
      between a more formal bookhand or uncial script, as compared to the Old
      Greek cursive script. You can also look at older Ptolemaic period Greek
      papyri that exhibit a cursive script here (incidentally, a cursive script
      could also be used for Latin texts as well--what is sometimes called the
      "Old Roman Cursive" script was used from the 1st-3rd C; while the "New Roman
      Cursive" took over in the later 3rd C and following).


      Hope this helps Jovial!

      Warm Regards;

    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.