Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

2956[textualcriticism] New Ending to the Gospel of Mark?

Expand Messages
  • K.Martin Heide
    Feb 24, 2007
      Dear all,

      There is at least another book in the Bible that does not have the expected ending.

      Malachi ends with 3:24 "He will restore the hearts of the fathers to their children and the hearts of the children to
      their fathers, so that I will not come and smite the land with a curse".

      But if you take e.g. the text of the famous Codex Leningradensis, you will find that right after this
      quite uncomfortable Finale, verse 23 is repeated again to smooth it up, as a 25th verse:

      "Behold, I am going to send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and
      terrible day of the LORD."

      Again, this smoothing up is orthodox, satisfies pious expectations and the human longing
      for harmony. The LE of Mark does the same, does'nt it? But the addition of the LE
      , instead of increasing to, takes away from the dramatical peak, from the cutting edge of the
      resurrection event. "Sometimes less is more". The same with Mal 3:25.


      Mark Thunderson wrote:

      Concerning another ending...

      It is amazing just how many attempts have been made to
      reach beyond Mark 16:8. Surely, the Gospel of Mark
      ends at 16:8. But to the credit of those who have
      argued for an extension beyond 16:8 (and these
      extensions have been less than satisfactory) , it does
      seem plausible that Mark 1:1-16:8 expects indeed hopes
      for closure. In order for the textual critic to
      perceive this, he must first understand what Mark is
      saying. So, I would argue on a very precise level
      that Mark expects his reader not only "to understand"
      but to continue the work he began (hence, Matthew and
      Luke). Therefore, those in the past who have written
      "an ENDING" have done so with little success. That an
      ending must come, however, is imminent. But who is
      worthy to write an end to Mark? Who is worthy to break
      the seal at 16:8?

      Mark Thunderson.

      --- Wieland Willker <willker@chemie. uni-bremen. de>

      > This may turn out to be interesting:
      > Stephen Carlson alerts us on his blog to this:
      > -----start blog quote------- --------- --------- ---
      > On the Crosstalk list, James Ernest, “new Markan
      > ending?� (Feb. 18, 2007), points out an intriguing
      > article from BYU, Mysteries of Ancient Egyptian
      > Papyri Revealed (Feb. 14, 2007). Here’s the beef:
      > "Three BYU professors have uncovered mysteries in
      > ancient Egyptian writings aided by new technology
      > that allows people to see inscriptions invisible to
      > the naked eye.
      > The professors Roger Macfarlane, Stephen Bay and
      > Thomas Wayment, have been working on deciphering
      > these writings on papyrus found in an Egyptian dump
      > where an ancient city known as Oxyrhynchus
      > previously existed. The papyri are now housed at the
      > University of Oxford in England and studied by
      > various scholars around the globe.
      > The technology developed by BYU called multispectral
      > imaging, can penetrate through dirt, stains and
      > other material on the papyri, making it possible to
      > expose obscured lettering.
      > Specific material in these texts include an
      > unidentified Christian apocryphal Gospel, a new
      > ending to the Gospel of Mark, a different version of
      > two verses in the book of Philemon, and a missing
      > section in Luke 22:43-44. In the King James Version,
      > these verses in Luke talk about Christ shedding
      > blood in the Garden of Gethsemane."
      > A “new ending to the Gospel of Mark�? What can
      > they possibly be talking about?
      > MORE: In any case, a new Oxyrhynchus papyrus scrap
      > of Mark (even without a “new ending�) would be
      > noteworthy. As best as I can tell from POxy:
      > Oxyrhynchus Online, no copy of the Gospel according
      > to Mark has yet been found among them.
      > UPDATE: April DeConick asks if multispectral
      > analysis can “help us with Saying 30 in the Gospel
      > of Thomas?� (Feb. 19, 2007).
      > NOTE: An email inquiry of mine (Feb. 20, 2007) has
      > not yet been answered, but, as of Feb. 21, 2007, the
      > news article has now disappeared from the BYU site.
      > -----end blog
      > quote------- --------- --------- --------- --------- ----
      > Just to repeat this:
      > - an unidentified Christian apocryphal Gospel
      > - a new ending to the Gospel of Mark
      > - a different version of two verses in the book of
      > Philemon,
      > - and a missing section in Luke 22:43-44
      > WOW!
      > Best wishes
      > Wieland
      > <><
      > ------------ --------- --------- --------- ---------
      > Wieland Willker, Bremen, Germany
      > mailto:willker@chemie. uni-bremen. de
      > http://www.uni- bremen.de/ ~wie
      > Textcritical commentary:
      > http://www.uni- bremen.de/ ~wie/TCG/ index.html

      ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _
      Don't get soaked. Take a quick peak at the forecast
      with the Yahoo! Search weather shortcut.
      http://tools. search.yahoo. com/shortcuts/ #loc_weather

    • Show all 16 messages in this topic