Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

[techbooks] REVIEW: "Bad Memory", Duane Franklet

Expand Messages
  • Rob Slade, doting grandpa of Ryan and Tr
    BKBDMMRY.RVW 20000122 Bad Memory , Duane Franklet, 1997, 0-671-00066-7 %A Duane Franklet %C 1230 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020 %D 1997
    Message 1 of 1 , Feb 28, 2000
    • 0 Attachment
      BKBDMMRY.RVW 20000122

      "Bad Memory", Duane Franklet, 1997, 0-671-00066-7
      %A Duane Franklet
      %C 1230 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020
      %D 1997
      %G 0-671-00066-7
      %I Simon & Schuster
      %O +1-212-698-7541
      %P 408 p.
      %T "Bad Memory"

      I liked this book. The plot is gripping, right up to the end. (The
      ending isn't exactly satisfying: you would think that Franklet, having
      dragged the reader through all manner of mayhem, would relent a bit
      and lighten up.) The central character is very sympathetic, as well
      as being very real. One part of the plot makes no sense, and doesn't
      fit with anything else, but it isn't essential, and doesn't
      necessarily detract from anything.

      The technology is generally pretty good, too. A lot of things are
      right, or almost so. (There is one piece of communications technology
      that seemed rather stupid to begin with, but turns out to be quite
      valid. Except that to discuss it would be to give the game away, and
      that wouldn't be fair.)

      Let's start with the technology parts that are right. The computer
      industry and work background is great. Realistic, not too far off the
      beam either way. The computers are authentic, if just a little bit
      dated for the time the book was written. The fact that computers
      would have different versions, levels, and configurations is true,
      though. The description of technical support is quite accurate. Even
      the undelete capability is used to good advantage.

      The specifics of various of the cracker attacks are unclear (not
      detailed), but don't work as well. The configuration of most machines
      that are described rely on DOS (possibly with Windows 3.x on top) and
      probably a Novell network. An H: drive is therefore probably not a
      local drive. An error message given at one point is for a floppy
      drive, not for a hard drive.

      "Address unavailable" wouldn't show up when doing low level packet
      sniffing on an Ethernet network. An Ethernet address could quite
      easily disappear from the net without a trace: all it would have to do
      is stop transmitting. (On Ethernet you don't want extraneous

      Windows, DOS, or Novell patches generally aren't distributed in the
      manner described, and certainly most of the patches so distributed
      would *not* immediately be implemented.

      A data security specialist would probably not hold an executive
      position at the level described. A company of the size and type
      described would probably have, at most, a handful of security people,
      rather than the department that seems to be available in the book. An
      outside security team of the type described would probably not be
      feasible: security is more of a management than a technical task, and
      having a bunch of outsiders come in and turn your company upside down
      would likely do more harm than good.

      One final note: cellular call detail definitely would be available to
      the account holder of record. Call detail, according to American law,
      must be made available to the paying party, and cell calls both made
      and received by the cell phone generate an airtime charge. Most
      people probably aren't aware of this, but even if you block caller ID,
      a call to an 800 number means the owner of the 800 number gets your

      copyright Robert M. Slade, 2000 BKBDMMRY.RVW 20000122

      ====================== (quote inserted randomly by Pegasus Mailer)
      rslade@... rslade@... slade@... p1@...
      Things are more like they are now than they ever were before.
      - Dwight Eisenhower
      http://victoria.tc.ca/techrev or http://sun.soci.niu.edu/~rslade
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.