22.11.13 : Retreat | How Many Horses Do You Need? | Grave Admonition Against Slander Of Pure Land Practice | Offering to 10,000 Monastics
- Quote: Retreat
TDE Web Store Is Open Realisation: How Many Horses Do You Need?
Not knowing what is enough,
you will never have enough,
even if you do have enough.
– Stonepeace | Get Books
Here is a Tibetan folk tale retold and extended:
The first brother has 1 horse.
The second brother has 99 horses.
None feel they have enough.
The first brother thinks,
'If only my brother would give me 1 horse,
my horse would have company!'
The second brother thinks,
'If only my brother would give me 1 horse,
my horses would number 100!'
Will both brothers be content with 1 more horse each?
For a while perhaps, but not for long,
before wanting more and more?
Which brother are you?
The first brother who seems to have less now,
or the second brother who seems to have much now?
Rich or poor, none can have enough or abundance
if one always wants more than needed.
'Contentment', the Buddha says, 'is the greatest wealth.'
Yet, worldly wealth cannot buy contentment,
as endless pursuit for it by gathering the material
is like chasing a carrot hanging on a stick in front.
What kind of 'horses' do you want?
Money, sense pleasures, fame, food, sleep…?
All are fleeting though, unlike bliss of spiritual liberation.
If you already have more than needed 'horses' and can get more,
why not generously help those in genuine need?
Be mindful not to spur greed in others though!
How many horses do I need?
None for me.
Support wildlife freedom and mass public transport!
Another Horse Story: Just Like That
Share Articles: tde@... Excerpt: Grave Admonition Against Slander Of Pure Land Practice
若有众生，If there are beings
闻是说者，who hear this [teaching],
应当发愿，they should vow [aspire]
生彼国土。to be born in that [Pure] Land [of Amituofo].
– 释迦牟尼佛 Śākyamuni Buddha
(佛说阿弥陀经 The Sūtra In Which The Buddha Speaks Of Amitā Buddha/ Amitābha Sūtra/
一切诸佛所护念经 The Sūtra Protected & Kept In Mind By All Buddhas)
[Reply letter to layman Wang Yu Mu by the 13th Patriarch of the Pure Land tradition Great Master Yin Guang (1861-1940); regarded in the Mahayana world as a manifestation of Mahasthamaprapta Bodhisattva]:
… The main tenet of Zen [Chan tradition] is to see one's Original Nature, while the teachings of Pure Land are [to nurture] Faith [in Amituofo], Vows [Aspiration] and [Practice of wholehearted] Reciting [or silent 'mindfulness of'] the Buddha's name [Amituofo; Amita(bha) Buddha] to achieve rebirth in the Pure Land. [Three Provisions: http://tinyurl.com/3provisons]
… on close examination, those of high capacities are few and far between [in this Dharma-Diminishing Age with the Five Defilements], while those of moderate and low capacities form the vast majority. This being the case,failing to teach people to develop Faith and Vows seeking rebirth in the Pure Land, while advising them to meditate on the Buddha's name [only as a koan (gong an); mondo (hua tou)] is utterly detrimental.
This is because, while awakening to the Way through [koan] meditation on the Buddha's name would be a fortunate development [if accomplished at all], an utterly sincere Vow for rebirth in the Pure Land would still be necessary [to truly benefit from the Amituofo's blessings for uninterrupted, expedited and non-retrogressible spiritual progress towards Buddhahood].
Meanwhile, if meditation is unsuccessful and the mind constantly grasps at the koan "who is reciting the Buddha's name," correspondence between the practitioner and the Buddha will be extremely diﬃcult to realize and the beneﬁt of the [Buddha's] "welcoming and escorting" Vow will be lost.
Those who really know "who is reciting the Buddha's name" are precisely those who have already awakened and clearly seen their True Nature. Nowadays, how many practitioners can meditate to the point of awakening to the Way? However, let us not speak about others. Even you and your friends have not reached that level. How do I know? It is because if you had, you would never have dared to make such [seriously wrong] statements as these in your letter: "the Pure Land method is an expedient [skillful means only] for ordinary people of limited capacities…; not knowing who is reciting the Buddha's name is not reciting in a mature way…; reciting a hundred thousand times a day has no relationship to the issue of Birth and Death…"
[Correction of wrong statements above: The Pure Land method is "the most skilful of all skilful means" for most beings at any point in time, as called by the 9th Patriarch of the Pure Land tradition Great Master Ou Yi. If one already knows "who is reciting", one does not need to in the first place. Diligent Practice in everyday life is needed to better ensure reaching Pure Land, which easier resolves the issue of Birth and Death.]
In truth, while your intention is to beneﬁt yourself and others equally, through your words you have not only erred yourself, you have led others astray as well. From now on, please desist from such talk. Otherwise, you will slam the door on and bury the all-embracing [Pure Land] method of the Buddhas to rescue sentient beings everywhere – preventing this method from being known far and wide. Such a transgression is tantamount to vilifying the Buddhas, the Dharma and the Sangha [as all Buddhas and great Bodhisattvas teach and praise the Pure Land path]. You should be careful indeed!
Since your understanding of the Dharma is not skillfully adapted to people's capacities… it is, in the end, a one-sided attachment – and a great mistake! Not realizing this, you think that you have correctly understood the subtle meaning of the Dharma and therefore seek my certiﬁcation. This monk… would not dare to commend, acquiesce in and support such a request, which would cause all of us to fall into the error of vilifying the Three Treasures [Triple Gem]!… I hope that you will reﬂect deeply on this letter.
Do Not Confuse Nianfo (Mindfulness Of Amituofo) With Other Practices
Danger Of Slandering Dharma Doors
The Pure Land Path Is For Everyone
Zen Master's Perspective Of The Pure Land Teachings
Buddha Mindfulness Is Not Inferior
The Noble Path And The Pure Land Path
Pure Land Courses
Comment | More
Pure Land Zen, Zen Pure Land: Letters From Patriarch Yin Guang [Letter 8]
Translated by Master Th'ich Thi'en T'am, et al [with annotations above by Shen Shi'an]
Sam & Sara:
Fortune : Sam & Sara (406)
Share Articles: tde@... Events & Notices See http://thedailyenlightenment.com/category/06 for faster & latest news
ODS: 24/11: Dharma Teaching & One-Day Vajrasattva 100-syllable Mantra Recitation Retreat by Sangye Nyenpa Rinpoche * 佛法讲座 与 一日金刚萨埵百字明咒闭关禅修 - 尊贵的桑杰年巴仁波切
Before 21/11: Offering to 10,000 Sangha 2013 * 敬造万尊莲师佛像 礼赠万僧殊胜福田
DDM: 27-30/12《心。生活》Fun 松体驗營 Youth Camp 2013
TPBC: 21/9-30/11: Understanding Amituofo Via The Amitabha Sutra (12th Run)
More Events: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/dharmanews/messages
To subscribe to the above, email firstname.lastname@example.org TDE-Weekly is a free independent Buddhist inspiration e-newsletter. You can support us by contributing news, articles, running costs and encouraging friends to join. Change (and cancellation) of emails, contributions, suggestions and queries are welcomed at tde@.... The information within the articles need not represent TDE's views.The copyrights of the articles belong to the authors.