Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Re: tc-list help please

Expand Messages
  • Harold P. Scanlin
    Fred Miller asked, ... the ... the ... seem ... You are right, both theories can t be right. I only intended to say that I favor explanation 1, but even if
    Message 1 of 3 , Mar 27, 1999
      Fred Miller asked,

      > Are there two thoughts presented here by your comments? That is 1. that
      > dots are remnants of partially erased letters of the NAME. Or 2. that
      > microscopically small letters are very precise but reflect a technology
      > mastered earlier and illustrated later in the middle ages, It does not
      > to me that it can be both.

      You are right, both theories can't be right. I only intended to say that I
      favor explanation 1, but even if they are micrography (not necessarily
      microscopically small) that is probably technologically possible.

      > I am
      > of the opinion that the strokes have a precise form not resembling Hebrew
      > Aramaic unless there are primitive alphabet scripts that I am not aware
      of that
      > would make the final two enscriptions resemble (if Hebrew) what looks
      like a
      > heth or tau upside down and the next to last marking resembles an
      oblique X
      > leaning to the left with elongated legs extending to the right, If this
      is the
      > next to last letter in the partially erased tetragrammaton it should be
      waw and
      > it does not seem to bear any resemblance to waw. As for erasures there
      do not
      > seem to be any places where residual strokes leave any evidence of having
      > abraided while however there is some "bleeding" between the letters which
      > be natural with such a small notation and would counter the idea of
      > since the bleeding has not been abraided at all..

      This is all possible, but the condition of the published plates prevents
      definitive conclusions. Martin offers at least a plausible case for
      remnants of the required letters, in Qumran orthography, for the

      Harold P. Scanlin
      United Bible Societies
      1865 Broadway
      New York, NY 10023
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.