At 10:27 AM 1/31/03 -0500, Maluflen@...
>In a message dated 1/30/2003 3:52:23 PM Eastern Standard Time, scarlson@... writes:
>> It looks like Osborne (sans "u") really got it wrong here. Yes, if
>> Osborne's characterization of the data was accurate (and they're quite
>> a bit more complicated in real life), then the shorter
>> reading canon
>> would tend to favor Matt. over Mark.
>If I am not mistaken, David J. Neville comes to a similar conclusion
>(favoring, if anything, Matthean priority with respect to Mark)in a recent
>Sheffield publication that studies in depth the so-called "argument from
>order". I haven't had time to read the book in full, so someone who has
>might wish to review it for the list.
I'm reading through the new Neville now, and I don't quite see (yet)
what you are referring to. Rather, Neville is analyzing the argument
from order (both formal and compositional) and comes to the conclusion
that this set of argumentation is indecisive with respect to solving
synoptic problem. Whether that is true or whether that is a failure
of nerve, I'll need more study to see, but I don't quite see Neville
as being pertinent to Osborne's mistake -- they seem to address different
I see to recall, though, that there as a proponent of the Griesbach
hypothesis who did point out that the expansive nature of the Markan
text should be considered an indication of Markan posteriority precisely
on account of the text critical rule, but I cannot recall now exactly
who it was who made that argument.
>All arguments converge... though see,
>of course, Peter Head for an opposite tending argument based on apparent
>theological development in Matt. By the way, I found a copy of Peter's book
>in a second-hand store recently, and bought it for $15. When I have time, I
>would like to take up some of his interesting arguments in favor of Markan
>priority on this list.
I would like to see this.
Stephen C. Carlson mailto:scarlson@...
Synoptic Problem Home Page http://www.mindspring.com/~scarlson/synopt/
"Poetry speaks of aspirations, and songs chant the words." Shujing 2.35
Synoptic-L Homepage: http://www.bham.ac.uk/theology/synoptic-l
List Owner: Synoptic-L-Owner@...