Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

[Synoptic-L] the origin of a synoptic hypothesis

Expand Messages
  • Brian E. Wilson
    ... Michael Grondin replied -- ... Michael, It is the way I have proceeded. I have considered hundreds of synoptic documentary hypotheses in my mind over the
    Message 1 of 11 , Sep 20, 2001
    • 0 Attachment
      Brian Wilson wrote:
      >To solve the synoptic problem, I would suggest the way to proceed is to
      >posit any synoptic documentary hypothesis at all, and test it against
      >the observed synoptic data. If it does not account easily for all the
      >data, then posit another hypothesis, and test this. And so on. Until a
      >hypothesis that works is found.
      Michael Grondin replied --
      >This doesn't strike me as the proper interplay between data and
      >hypothesis. No one does it this way, as far as I know, nor does it seem
      >a particularly promising procedure.
      It is the way I have proceeded. I have considered hundreds of
      synoptic documentary hypotheses in my mind over the years, and rejected
      virtually all of them by testing them against the observed data.
      >The aggregate of data, as we interpret it, already suggests to each of
      >us a subset of hypotheses we find most plausible, and we start with
      >them, not with a random selection from a finite list of possible
      >hypotheses. ...
      I would suggest that where we start is irrelevant. However plausible a
      hypothesis may seem, if it does not fit the data well it is not a
      solution. We are not looking for a merely plausible hypothesis. We are
      looking for a hypothesis that can objectively be shown to work when
      tested against the observable data. However "plausible" a hypothesis, if
      testing it against the data shows that it does not work, then it is not
      a solution. The point is that no hypothesis of the documentary
      relationship between the synoptic gospels can be deduced from the
      observed data. A hypothesis is not a theorem produced at the end of a
      chain of reasoning, but a question at the start of a line of

      The same is true in astronomy. However many observations are made
      through telescopes of the relative positions of the planets and moons in
      our solar system at given times, there is no way in which Newton's law
      of gravitation, or Einstein's general theory (which includes a theory of
      gravitation) can be deduced from the observed data. All Newton or
      Einstein could do was make an imaginative guess, and check this against
      the observed facts to see whether it works. Einstein was thrilled when
      he realized that the observed change in the orbit of Mercury about the
      sun was consistent with his gravitational theory (in his theory of
      general relativity). He says that he "walked on air" for a fortnight
      afterwards. The reason, however, was that he realized that his general
      theory of relativity fitted well this data. When tested against the
      data, the hypothesis worked. He was glad to find not that he had deduced
      anything from observed data, but that his leap of imagination that was
      his basic theory fitted the observed data well.

      I think we should be clear that no synoptic documentary hypothesis has
      been, or can be, deduced from the data provided by the synoptic gospels
      themselves, and that the route by which a synoptic hypothesis is
      obtained is irrelevant. What matters is whether the hypothesis is shown
      to work when tested against the data.

      Best wishes,

      >HOMEPAGE *** RECENTLY UPDATED *** http://www.twonh.demon.co.uk/

      Rev B.E.Wilson,10 York Close,Godmanchester,Huntingdon,Cambs,PE29 2EB,UK
      > "What can be said at all can be said clearly; and whereof one cannot
      > speak thereof one must be silent." Ludwig Wittgenstein, "Tractatus".

      Synoptic-L Homepage: http://www.bham.ac.uk/theology/synoptic-l
      List Owner: Synoptic-L-Owner@...
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.