[Synoptic-L] Re: Midrash without Midrash; was Historical writing: was Genealogies...
- To: Leonard Maluf,
<< I hope you understand by now that it is not my position that part of
Matthew's and Luke's genealogy intend to refer to non-historical people. I
simply question whether the Evangelists intended to be writing history, or
writing narrative in some other genre. >>
On the one hand, you seem to want to claim (and you have so claimed in past
messages) that the Evangelists did not intend to be writing "history." And
when asked for an example, you pointed out the genealogies of Jesus which
appear in Matthew and Luke. Yet, on the other hand, when asked for you to
point out which parts of the genealogies you think Matthew and/or Luke held
to be non-historical, you come up completely empty.
I've also asked you to cite other ancient midrashic documents which would
support your position, but (to date) you have cited NOTHING!
On October 29, you wrote: << How do I interpret the texts? That is really
too broad a question to be broached here. It is easier to say simply that I
don't interpret them the way you do, namely, apparently, as intending to
tell a straightforward story with literal historical references. They are
more midrashic in character, theology in narrative form, in my view, and
Luke understood Matthew's narrative to be such. Thus he could write a
"better" infancy narrative than Matthew, using something close to the same
kind of writing as he, and therefore not to be charged with inconsistency
of historical detail which neither narrative was intended to supply. >>
I've tried asking you to point out where this supposed "midrashic"
character of the gospels appear in these gospels. But so far you come up
empty! It seems that on the one hand, you want to claim that the gospel
writings are "more midrashic in character," and yet, on the other hand, you
cannot point to one place in the gospels which is "midrashic in character."
Gosh, that must make it difficult for you to defend your hypothesis, yes?
-Steven Craig Miller
Alton, Illinois (USA)
Disclaimer: "I'm just a simple house-husband (with no post-grad degree),
what do I know?"