5930Re: [Synoptic-L] Luke knew Matthew: Three versions
- Apr 10, 2001At 02:06 PM 4/10/01 +0100, Peter M. Head wrote:
>There seem to be three different views among those who think that Luke knewYes. The Augustinians (Zahn, Jameson, Chapman, Butler, and Wenham in
>a) Griesbach Hyp view: Lk used Mt as his major source (e.g. Old Griesbach
>School, Farmer, Q Impasse)
>b) Farrer-Goulder Hyp view: Lk used Mt as supplement to Mk, therefore
>dispense with Q (e.g. Farrer, Goulder, Drury, Ropes, Enslin [I think some
>Americans have held this view!], Goodacre)
>c) 2SH view: Lk exhibits occasional knowledge of Mt, but primary sources
>were Mk & Q (Gundry, later Holtzmann, Morganthaler).
>i) Have I missed anyone important?
the 20th century). Although the Augustinians and Farrer theory Q
skeptics disagree on Markan priority, their views on Luke's use of
Matthew and Mark are compatible. (Though the Q skeptics, who hold
to Markan priority without Q, have the better psychological argument
for Luke's preference for Mark: Luke had known Mark for longer.)
>ii) Does anyone know anything about E. Simon, Hat der dritte Evangelist denAll I know is what Hobbs explained. Simons was like your view
>kanonischen Matthäus benutzt (Bonn: C. Georgi, 1880)? Apparently influenced
>Holtzmann, mentioned in Farmer, Synoptic Problem. Where does he fit into
(c), which has been termed the Three Source Hypothesis (Mark, Q,
and Matthew). Holtzmann worked with Simons on this issue, which
allowed Holtzmann to abandon Ur-Markus.
>iii) If one was going to argue the opposite (i.e. Luke's independence fromI would argue them separately. They are different and raise different
>Matthew) would it be fair to treat the issue globally, or would one need a
>detailed critique of each of the three options?
kinds of issues.
Stephen C. Carlson mailto:scarlson@...
Synoptic Problem Home Page http://www.mindspring.com/~scarlson/synopt/
"Poetry speaks of aspirations, and songs chant the words." Shujing 2.35
Synoptic-L Homepage: http://www.bham.ac.uk/theology/synoptic-l
List Owner: Synoptic-L-Owner@...
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>