thinking about it, not doing it (was: Re: Stoicism in practice
- --- In email@example.com, "Keith Seddon" <K.H.S@b...> wrote:
> Hello Jim,rather poor
> >>>I have a tendency to judge by deeds, not intentions. I am a
> You cannot judge by deeds. Whatever it is you see someone doing, or
> to do, you cannot directly see their motives and intentions. One'sin that
> conjecture as to what motivated someone is one thing: being correct
> conjecture is something else.Roger that. And since all I have to go on is DEEDS, what else is
there? People lie and pose. Sad, but true.
> Someone who tries to save the drowning person but fails is not lessvirtuous
> or praiseworthy than the person who tries and succeeds. But if youjudge by
> deeds, you will have to say the person who succeeds is morevirtuous than
> the person who tries but fails. Virtue resides in the trying, notin the
> trying and succeeding.Under those circumstances, I would use the their action and the
results to evaluate their wisdom/judgement. I would not be qualified
to judge their virtueness, and would not. Stupid, yes. Like in the
movie: 'Stupid is as stupid does.' Virtuous, dunno.
> Malcolm wrote:
> Externals are, according to the Discipline of Action, something that a Stoic should care deeply about.
> Caring, as in an 'emotional investment' type of caring? About something outside one's control? Malcolm, this is contrary to everything I know about Stoicism. Maybe you can summarize the Discipline of Action and give me some references, but right now on the face of it this does not sound Stoic at all.
>..............................Steve,Although this goes back to 4 Sept., I want to add a little more because it involves a point that I think is important, and frequently misunderstood.The discipline of action does require that Stoics concern themselves with the common good. This inevitably involves externals which are not in our power, although perhaps not truly externals because all reasoning beings are considered limbs of the Universal Reason.As important as the exercise of indifference (a part of the discipline of desire) is, service to humanity is central to Stoic philosophy. Stoicism is not a philosophy of disengagement from life; but is rather a philosophy of engagement in life, and of service to humanity.See the two quotes below.Malcolm SchoshaIn a system comprising diverse elements, those which possess reason have the same part to play as the bodily limbs in an organism that is a unity; being similarly constituted for mutual cooperation. This reflection will impress you more forcibly if you constantly tell yourself, 'I am a "limb" (melos) of the whole complex of rational things.' If you think of yourself as a 'part' (meros) only, you have as yet no love from the heart for mankind, and no joy in the performance of acts of kindness for their own sake. You do them as a bare duty, and not yet as good offices to yourself. Meditations, 7.13 Staniforthor Seneca, speaking of the Stoic school:No school has more goodness and gentleness; none has more love for human beings, nor more attention to the common good. The goal which it assigns to us is to be useful, to help others, and to take care, not only of ourselves, but of everyone in general and of each one in particular. On Clemency, 3.3 Hadot (in The Inner Citadel, p231)
Click here to donate to the Hurricane Katrina relief effort.