6046Re: [soaplite] POST & Host lines in http request
- Nov 2, 2007Lev Lvovsky wrote:
> Replying to my own post here, perhaps this is a developer questionI'm not an expert on HTTP but nobody else has answered so here's my 2p
> (not sure if the developer of SOAP::Lite is on this list):
> It seems that according to this w3.org link: http://www.w3.org/
> the 'Host:' header is a requirement of HTTP 1.1. I see that the
> SOAP::Lite module is hardcoding version '1.1' in the HTTP request,
> however is not setting the 'Host:' header. Additionally, the "POST"
> part of the request contains the whole URL which should be split up
> between these two header fields.
> Any comments, input, etc?
> On Oct 25, 2007, at 4:37 PM, Lev Lvovsky wrote:
>> Is there any way to split up the http request created by the
>> SOAP::Lite package so that instead of an http header like this:
>> POST https://foo.com/bar1/bar2.extension HTTP/1.1
>> we get something like:
>> POST: /bar1/bar2.extension HTTP/1.1
>> Host: foo.com
>> The server which I'm now submitting our SOAP query to doesn't like
>> the first format anymore, and insists on the second.
FWIW, my reading of the spec agrees with you and your server
implementation: "A client MUST include a Host header field in all
HTTP/1.1 request messages". But as I say, I'm no expert.
So if we accept for a moment that there's a problem, the next question
is whose problem? SOAP::Transport::HTTP uses LWP's HTTP::Request and
HTTP::Headers packages, so is it driving them incorrectly or are they
broken? Looking at their POD, I see examples that don't have Host
headers and I don't see any examples that do!
So it may be worth rephrasing your question and asking it on the
<libwww@...> mailing list.
- << Previous post in topic