11247Re: [snowkiteidaho] Re: Baja log...
- Feb 12, 2013Thanks for opinion Joel. The central point you made was: "You don't have the right, as a foreign national, to run a business in Mexico, which, the way they see it, is what you are doing."Because "they" may claim my action to be a business does not mean that view truly conforms to Mexican law.I searched but could not find any passages of Mexican law that classify the one-time sharing of rides by gringos, or sharing of hotel rooms (when one pays the bill then takes money from the others in equal shares), or similarly pooling funds for grocery purchases as "running service businesses". Universally, businesses are defined as ongoing activities (not one time, non-ongoing actions) with a profit objective. These ride & hotel & grocery cost-sharing actions certainly don't meet the universal definition of business. I'd welcome a reference to any such Mexican statutes that establish otherwise. If those things are truly illegal in Mexico, and this becomes broadly known by gringos, I think that may undoubtedly and unfortunately further dampen gringo enthusiasm for Mexican toursim.I'll reserve a more complete response for when I'm outside Mexico, as clearly your preoccupation to find & respond to my simple, innocent blog post in the tiny group 'snowkiteidaho' raises many questions about who and where you are, and other motives you may have.JonOn Tue, Feb 12, 2013 at 1:04 AM, RUSTY HILL <rustyshill@...> wrote:Wow, never met you, Joel, but it may have been better to send your angry email directly to whom you're angry with. The rest of us like to "keep it clean" and avoid fighting on these email groups. Thanks
On Feb 12, 2013, at 12:46 AM, "ruddercraft" <sailboats@...> wrote:
I'm not sure you understand, but the Mexican law prohibits gringos from buying goods and services from other gringos who don't have an FM3 visa and a business in Mexico.
There was no threat of the "little bite" from the Federales, because you were legitimately breaking the law. They had the power to detain and/or arrest you for breaking the law in Mexico because you were charging the other guys riding with you for the fuel, convenience, or whatever.
You don't have the right, as a foreign national, to run a business in Mexico, which, the way they see it, is what you are doing.
I'm sure you expect foreign nationals visiting the US to abide by our laws, you should try to do the same while in Mexico. The shuttle operators who "charge a lot more $" are running businesses and feeding their families, they are not your ride share competition. If they complain to the local authorities about it being unfair and illegal that you are charging riders, they're right, they are not being predatory, as you suggest.
Mexico is a cheap place to enjoy their natural resources of fun, sun, wind, surf and reef like Cabo Pulmo, and for you to complain about them trying to enforce their laws set up to protect their little businesses is ridiculous. That kind of attitude makes it hard on the rest of us gringos who follow the Mexican rules while in Mexico, because we know we're in their country.
If you don't want to use their shuttle service, don't. If you think their prices are too high, then negotiate using your "good spanish" but don't slam them for trying to make a living in a hard-scrabble place like Baja, when all those people do is extend kindness to Americans 99.9% of the time.
I've spent a lot of time sailing in Mexico, I've been all the places you have, and from what I've seen, the Mexicans are a lot more honorable that we are, most of the time.
Keep in mind how you'd like foreigners to act in your hometown and you'll do better.
See you out there,
P.S. you will virtually never be hit for mordida by Federales. That is a local cop thing.
--- In firstname.lastname@example.org, Jon Bolt wrote:
> So much to report, can't do it all, and takes too much time away from other
> "divertido", so I've just blown it off. but to ease some guilt, here's a
> couple snippets...
> Only a few no wind days so far since arrival Jan 15. Even the days where
> Baja Joe's shows no wind, most times it's kitable just fine up here at
> north beach. Smallest kite I've used so far is 11.5m, including yesterday,
> but money kite here has been 9.5m in sweet conditions. When the strongest
> El Norte's come through, it's cool highs maybe 70 or little more, but if El
> Norte's are mild, the local thermal winds add to them, so still good strong
> wind and could be in shorties, some w/ no wetsuits. 5-6 days ago there was
> strong El Norte, but with a westerly component where wind tumbles over
> mountains before hitting beach making it gusty & holey & side-off, so we
> went way around the bay to a spot where that westerly hits side-on but its
> at very end of bay w/ huge swell & waves breaking directly on shore.
> Coarse sand blowing & stinging all exposed skin. Went out on 7.5m & had
> to almost totally depower (yikes! coulda easily done 5.5m but it back at
> our place) and still boosting huge but scary in those rough waters since
> you're taking off where a preceeding wave leaves a slick behind and have to
> land w/o getting cremed by following wave. Swell & breaking waves surely
> mast high, they swallow you in between. Way rough. The real deal...ran
> out of adrenalin after about an hour. Not much tricks other than jumping
> lunar, rest spent getting upwind & playing on & between waves. Only a
> handful of most experienced kiters at that spot because water entry through
> that huge surf is challenging, and conditions rough. But most days here
> are sweet fun 9.5m. The wind forecast for today was zilch, but right now
> it's already whitecapping at least 12m...no...just looked out & it's 9m so
> game on today.
> My buddy had to go back to states for 5 days, so Monday upon his return I
> drove down to Cabo airport to pick him up in his pickup and took trailered
> dirtbikes to do adventure on the way back. Tell you later about trip to
> airport where I got stopped in both La Paz & @ Cabo airport by Policia
> Federale, taking all our ID & vehicle documents, wanting to arrest me,
> write ticket, and confiscate truck & trailer & bikes & tow to a yard
> ("gruas"), all because I gave rides (in exchange for gas money) to other
> local windjunkies who advertised in local email bulletin board looking for
> a ride to airport. Claimed I was operating a service business w/o permit
> (thus competing w/ local Mexicans that offer this service for a lot more
> $$). Because the Mexicans charge so much, local gringos put notices of
> rides wanted & available in daily email bulletin board, hoping to ride
> share instead of paying the spendy shuttle cost. Interesting story for
> later how they found out I was giving 3 folks a ride to the airport, and
> identified my vehicle so they were watching for it in both places. Pegged
> the stress & stomach acid needles, and after major intimidation, requiring
> us to follow them to their "offices", and cutting me out of the herd for
> application of special scare tactics, they both let me go w/ warning (after
> about 30 minutes of threats & intimidation each time), and we didn't offer
> or pay any mordida. Persist w/ reasonable protest & good enough spanish
> (and claiming inability to understand whenever advantageous) long enough to
> wear them down, which gives time for other bigger events to arise which
> require their presence elsewhere. they were basically acting at the behest
> of a shuttle operator, and apparently on the phone to him to get his
> version of the facts (so policeman would sound informed) at same time he
> was grilling me. So I got good experience dealing w/ Federales...and the
> militant tactics of local shuttle operators trying to prevent gringos from
> sharing rides to the airports. I'm gonna write a "head's up" in the local
> bulletin board system alerting gringos of these predatory tactics by
> shuttle operators trying to obstruct gringo ride sharing, which will dent
> their business for sure.
> After the Federales we drove to the fairly remote (i.e., washboarded dirt
> road access for many miles) Cabo Pulmo where there is a true Marine Reserve
> having the only coral reef in Sea of Cortez, and south of that a fantastic
> string of remote big white sand beaches and big rocky mountains coming down
> to those beaches, the first such beach is Los Frailes. This area generally
> referred to as the remotest part of the "East Cape". Stayed the night in
> Cabo Pulmo and in morning the sea life display along the reserve was
> epic...schools of rays, dolphins, multiple whale pods, all reasonably close
> to shore. Hopped on bikes and did morning ride 20 miles or more south to
> discover more pristine beaches. Mid-day returned to truck and drove back
> to Los Barriles for 12m kiting session, then home to LV. When forecast
> shows a couple no wind days, we'll certainly head back there for
> snorkeling, camping, where you can fish from shore outside the Reserve, or
> buy fresh fish from the panganero fisherman camps present at many of the
> good beaches. One of most inspiring & exciting parts of Baja we've seen.
> All for now. 9m beckons...
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>