Re: Veteran Opinions on proposed Device
- View SourceI have to totally agree with Sara. Your first choice rocks and I
conflict checked it also (I'm a herald that's what I do :-) ) and I
concur no conflicts. I have to also agree that your second choice
although very nice is so over done in the SCA that I would steer away
from it. But, at least it isn't bend sinister (although done a lot in
the SCA isn't really a good period type choice).
I'd say get your paperwork all lined out and when your wayward herald
returns from Pennsic...submit...submit...submit!
(Who hopes one day to also be a wayward herald at Pennsic!)
- View SourceWhat if I changed the griffin to Or and made the pheon Sable. My
partner is also looking to register a device and has fallen in love
with this one. Suggestions? Thank you
--- In firstname.lastname@example.org, Sara L Uckelman <liana@...>
> Quoth "welshdane":
> > Greetings all.
> > I have uploaded 2 pictures for opinions. They are my 1st and 2nd
> > choice for a personal device for registration. My local herald
> > at Pennsic War and I am interested in getting comments.something
> Wow, I *really* like your first choice. Clear, simple, classic
> design...this is the sort of thing great heraldry is all about.
> This would be blazoned "Azure, a tree blasted and eradicated and
> on a chief argent, three pheons sable." I found no conflicts with
> currently registered armory, so I see no bars to registration if
> this is the design you chose to go with.
> Your second one, "Per bend argent and azure, a pheon and a griffin
> passant counterchanged," has no stylistic problems, but the motif
> "Per bend X and Y, two different charges counterchanged" is
> that's really overused in the SCA, compared to how often it was
> done in the Middle Ages. I found no conflicts, so it would be
> registerable, but if you want arms which impress people with their
> Good Period Style, I'd definitely recommend the first over the
> vita sine literis mors est
- View Source"welshdane" <schnauzer2@...> wrote:
>I can't offer any advice, being a newbie myself, but I would love to
> I have uploaded 2 pictures for opinions.
see what you have done, Where can I see them?
Tiffany for now
- View SourceQuoth "welshdane":
> What if I changed the griffin to Or and made the pheon Sable. MyI didn't see any conflicts with that tincture combination either, but
> partner is also looking to register a device and has fallen in love
> with this one. Suggestions? Thank you
the use of four different tinctures instead of two does make this
resemble period style even less than the other one did.
vita sine literis mors est