Re: [rss-public] Winer's Comment
- * Clinton Gallagher <csgallagher@...> [2006-02-20 23:20]:
>So there must be a "however" -- and I know you were all waitingOkay, it took me a long time to plow through your verbiage, but I
>with baited breath for the 'however' right? :-) -- if we agree
>to respect the road map and only [amend | change | modify |
>update | clarify | whatever ] the documentation so as to
>"clarify" without responding to the fact that certain elements
>as implemented are in fact dysfunctional we will only needlessly
>perpetuate that which is dysfunctional simply because we have
>been too ashamed of our own shortcomings which do not allow us
>to maturely accept change which must in fact be made anyhow
>while pointing the finger at Dave Winer because after all, it
>was all his fault anyway; noting for those with reading
>comprehension deficits that I do not hold to that asinnine
>conclusion but do support and advocate both the major and minor
>premise from which it could improperly be drawn.
think I finally got the gist.
Basically, you’re saying that it is cowardly to let deficiencies
in RSS 2.0 stand as they are in deference to Dave Winer’s wishes,
despite the board knowing and having acknowledged that there are
>Nor do I appreciate it being left up to me to support this lieNoone said it is forbidden for you to say that RSS 2.0 is broken,
>when compelled to explain and rationalize to people I work with
>or for who do not understand these facts when in the previous
>breath I was asking them to trust me because I am a man of
if that is your belief. Shout it from the rooftops, if you care
to. You wouldn’t be the first.
>Truth is the elephant. coo-coo ka choo.The truth is that RSS 2.0 is Dave Winer’s thing, and you can take
it or leave it – it’s not going to change.
Some people had complaints like yours, and since RSS 2.0 is
Winer’s thing, they left it and made Atom. If you feel morally
offended by having to use a format you consider broken, the
choice is yours to leave RSS 2.0 as well.
This is not the place to make RSS 2.0 into Atom. This is the
place to make RSS 2.0 into more of RSS 2.0.
So in closing, I say…
“You must be new here.”
Aristotle Pagaltzis // <http://plasmasturm.org/>