Re: Disposable battery taillights review
I suspect that the Radbot flashing mode is designed at least partly to conserve batteries. AAA batteries have very little capacity compared to AA size, about 30 to 40% as much. If run continuously at full rated power of the LED, 1 watt, the run time of the Radbot would be about 1 hour. The flashing mode is distinctive though probably less so than the Superflash with the secondary LEDs that are only used in flashing mode.
This makes me suspicious of the actual driving current to the LED in continuous burn mode. The LED cannot be running at anything near full rated power. Still quite bright though.
BTW these power comments also apply to ALL of the AAA battery high power taillights. None are having their LEDs driven at full power or their bttery lives would be unacceptably short.
To me the ideal consumablle battery taillight would have the following characteristics.
2. Distinctive and clearly noticeable blinking pattern(s) available. Use secondary LEDs if required, as in the Superflash, for the most noticeable flashing modes possible.
3. Broad beam to the rear.
4. Very wide angle of view secondary LEDs positioned on the sides for side safety lights.
5. Preferably use AA batteries for longer run time and more power available.
All current battery lights fall short in respect to items 3 and 4 IMO.
--- In firstname.lastname@example.org, "speedub_nate" <speedub.nate@...> wrote:
> There are some videos of the Radbot vs. the Superflash on YouTube. It certainly is brighter than the Superflash, but its flashing mode is curious. I'll have to check one out in person. I imagine Planet Bike will have a Superflash update in the coming months.
> The Cateye random mode is useless to me. I believe the two rows are on independent circuits and move in and out of phase. While this looks good in the store, out on the street at night is loses visual contrast and doesn't broadcast that "punch" of light to grab a motorists attention, which is why I love the Superflash so dearly.
- Here is a link to a write up of the Light & Motion Vis 180 rechargeable one piece taillight assembly.
No price listed but I bet that it will be in the close to $100 range.
--- In email@example.com, "poppamando" <b4kids@...> wrote:
> Rich, thanks for the reply and for all your work! I can certainly understand the need for being budget minded these days given the tight economy and it's impact on many of us (our family included).
> On the note of being budget minded, good reflectors and reflective tape placed well can be life saving when your batteries go.
--- In firstname.lastname@example.org, "Rich" <astronut1001@...> wrote:
> To me the ideal consumablle battery taillight would have the following characteristics.
> 3. Broad beam to the rear.I think this item is overrated.I mean, sure, a wide beam is good if there is plenty of light to project rearward. But this is always a compromise resulting in reduced visibility.An approaching vehicle is going to be in that "sweet spot," the slender cone within a couple of degrees directly centered behind your bike, right up until it's passing, at which point it had better have already seen you.If the beam is being scattered sideways in the name of side visibility, the amount of light being projected directly back at approaching vehicles is being diminished. I don't see the usefulness in that.I'd rather have a wide beam up front, so that vehicles at cross streets have a better chance of seeing me. But that's where my helmet light comes in handy.