- I just love being misquoted out of context. My comment was a response
to the following:
--- In pcgen@y..., "Mark Hulsman" <hulsmanm@p...> wrote:
>> I got a question. Instead of having a choose pop up, is there a
>> specify what you want? I mean the toughness feat never change so
>> gotta pick the 3 hp each and every time? :) I rather specify it
>> prestige class and not having to deal with a popup window.
> Well you have to have the pop up eac time for toughness because
> any feat that can be taken multiple times has to have a choose. If
> add a little functionality to choose so that if it only had one
> would automatically take tht one it would be really good.
--- In pcgen@y..., Keith Davies <kjdavies@t...> wrote:
> Scott Ellsworth wrote on Mon Dec 31 14:56:05 2001:
> > On Monday, December 31, 2001, at 12:33 AM, Keith Davies wrote:
> > > gsbingl wrote on Sun Dec 30 23:49:53 2001:
> > >> The choose pop up needs to be there in case you want to get
rid of a
> > >> selected feat.
> > >
> > > FWIW, in conversation with folks from WotC, if you take a feat
> > > later granted by a class you take, you just have to suck it up.
> > On the other hand, it is really easy to miss-click, or to select
> > that the DM does not, for his own reasons, allow in the game. If
> > not have such a UI, then people would get to regenerate their
> > from scratch.
> > A paper sheet would just have to have an eraser applied to it.
> > A system like "no changing once you level up" does not help the
> > DM creating a character in a massive frenzy, where he may level
up a few
> > times and then select feats.
> > So, even if WOTC does not allow it for real characters, we have
> > it for typos and changes.
> That makes sense. I understood that could be done on the Feat tab;
> thought it would be redundant and unnecessary here, which is why I
> commented on it... it sounded like the earlier poster was
> it was useful to allow players to remove selected feats when they
> later granted as virtual or bonus feats on selecting a new class or
> reaching a particular level -- which goes against what I understand
> Minor rules point, that's all...
> Keith Davies
> Elarios: "Shade, you showed honor and mercy
> "Raven, you were couragous beyond expectation
> "Logan, you resisted the temptation of knowledge."
> Logan: "That's... good, right?"
- Brass Tilde wrote on Tue Jan 1 05:51:41 2002:
>Oh boy! Make things *more* complicated! <g>
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: Keith Davies
> > gsbingl wrote on Sun Dec 30 23:49:53 2001:
> > >
> > > The choose pop up needs to be there in case you want to get rid of a
> > > selected feat.
> > FWIW, in conversation with folks from WotC, if you take a feat that is
> > later granted by a class you take, you just have to suck it up. For
> > instance, taking 'Martial Weapon Proficiency' as a rogue, say, then
> > later taking a level of fighter, does not free up the slot previously
> > assigned to MWP.
> Though it sdhould be noted that some classes that confer feats also provide
> for an alternative in the event the PC already has the feat. The Weapon
> Master and Improved Critical come to mind.
Elarios: "Shade, you showed honor and mercy
"Raven, you were couragous beyond expectation
"Logan, you resisted the temptation of knowledge."
Logan: "That's... good, right?"