I wanted to share this 3:30PM post on Ed Notes before the PEP. Occupy and Stay! Don't Walk Away as UFT Changes Plans (Again)
The draft was updated all day as new info kept coming in and we were all trying to figure out exactly what the UFT was trying to do.
I actually heard a rumor that they were hiding their intentions because of worry Ed notes and other blogs might give it away --- like it really would make a difference. See UFT Staff Director Leroy Barr's somewhat astounding email at around 2:45PM announcing a change in plans. As one reporter said to me last night -- "they are usually pretty smart but this was really dumb."
The press finally caught the reality that ODOE is not backed or supported by the UFT (as Walcott idiotically claimed).
Given what actually happened last night there is a lot to think about. The event began with some serious tension between ODOE and the UFT with counter calls to each group. We have video of a lot of that. The coming together at the end seemed to make people feel good -- and some of the press caught that.
The fact that everyone sort of came together with ODOE actually walking out before the vote is an issue -- though a small group did stay.
Thanks to everyone who worked so hard to put this together. I think we learned some things --- like it is not only about the people's mic when they pump up the volume --- have whistles and horns to counter that. As Patrick said -- when they can't hear there may be some wiggle room. I hope that on March 1 when they hand Eva Williamsburg ODOE and other groups can make enough noise --- expect Success to have a crew while the UFT will not be there in force.
In the meantime the next big event for many is Thurs Feb. 16 at MS 50. A parent group is planning a march around the neighborhood starting around 4 or 4:30 pm, signup to speak at 5:30 (Eva is organizing for that too to bring in carpetbaggers).
More on ed notes later.
Here are some links to press coverage. Assessing the Impact
The skinny on what's happening today (info coming in all day). This is last call: 3:30 PM
The overall agenda inside the PEP:
- Set up the People’s Mic (ignoring the DOE’s electronic ones and
speaker set up)
- Introductions and explanation of the People’s Pep and process;
- Roll call of affected schools and communities;
- Vote of No Confidence;
- Public Comments via the People’s Mic – school by school,
initially led by a few speakers from each - including elected and other
officials should they so choose;
- People’s Pep roll call vote on each of the school closings and
- Additional public comments
UFT Foments Pissing Contest by not going in
FROM LEO BARR c. 2:45PM
Michael Mulgrew will do a press conference at 5:30pm outside
of Brooklyn Tech on DeKalb Ave. WE ARE NOT GOING IN TO THE PEP AT BROOKLYN
TECH! We will gather on the park side of DeKalb Ave. and begin to march at
6pm, led by Mulgrew, politicians and community people. Look for the UFT
feather (vertical banner).
Leo Casey will go inside with 10 people from each borough to
pass out a letter from Michael Mulgrew inviting people to come over to PS 20K.
DR’s, we need you to reach out to your people and let them
know of the change in plans so that we have a large crowd marching with Michael
Mulgrew. Thanks everyone!
In or out? The UFT plays a divisive game that benefits Bloomberg by walking out and not disrupting.
- Live steam http://goo.gl/wZJFb
Advisory: Occupy the Department of Education Will Occupy The Panel for
Educational Policy to Stop the Vote on School Closures and
- DOE plans for tonight: vote behind stage in gym or hold meeting Feb. 13.
- UFT will not go in en masse but send 10 reps from each borough in to urge people to leave
Our chapter leader is passing out UFT neck straps and big bright
laminated badges that say "People's PEP" and the name of our school. He
says the plan is to enter the auditorium after the rally & then walk
out & assemble at the other location (with a small auditorium).
- Coalition of groups: We are not leaving but will use the people's
mic to vote to keep all schools open. Each school will be able to send
reps to speak their piece not to the PEP but the real public.
- There will be no storming of the stage, no blocking of the
aisles, no chaos. Just a well-organized demonstration of the People’s
will and voice and, we hope, a mass movement toward demanding systemic
- Coalition does education campaign to public: what PEP is, how
decisions are made in advance no matter how you pour your heart out,
etc. (http://youtu.be/NYjRRNCMuBM and http://youtu.be/rbDdfAEnJ34).
- Ultimate goal it to build support to shut down mayoral control.
- Following to be distributed today to all schools urging them not leave the PEP.
Tweed has a plan: hold vote in gym
Given the expected disruption and use of people's mic tonight to hold an
alternate meeting within a meeting, the DOE has a few choices. One is
to come down with a heavy hand and threaten people. How this would play
out in front of the press and public may not be very good for the
massive PR team at Tweed to manage. More likely to happen is this:
We have heard that the DOE has made contingency plans on how to hold the
vote to close 23 schools at the PEP at Brooklyn Tech. One source says
an alternate space is being set up behind the stage in the gym behind
the auditorium. Another that they have reserved Brooklyn Tech for
February 13 to redo the meeting if necessary. One would expect very
heightened security no matter what but if they decide to redo look for
them to restrict access in some manner to prevent a repeat. One of
Tweed's strategies may be to let the disruption play out tonight and
then use the attack dogs in the Murdoch controlled press to blame the
UFT and justify heavy police presence on Feb. 13. All this is still
Walcott blames UFT for Occupy, further proof he doesn't have a clue
But Walcott said he would not let tonight’s meeting be driven off
course by protesters and accused the union of masterminding the Occupy
protest in addition to its own.
UFT was not sure what to do - stay or go--but decision to walk will lead to blowback.
“There are important proposals up for discussion tonight and my hope
is that we will have a respectful process where people can be heard,”
Walcott said in a statement. “But if all the UFT wants to do is bus in
Occupy Wall Street to disrupt public meetings — which provides
absolutely no benefit to students — then we will just have to work
around that. We are prepared to move forward even if there are
Like Walcott, the press attack dogs will blame the UFT for whatever
happens tonight. That is far from what has really been going on. Given
all the activist groups the opportunity for the UFT to play Big Dog is
not as operative as it has been in the past. In fact the UFT has
resisted the push from ODOE to stay and hold a meeting within the
meeting. They are still sending out mixed signals, telling different
schools different things.
The UFT will not send people into the meeting other than 50 reps urging
people to leave and head over to nearby PS 20 where the auditorium holds
600 people. The UFT's original plan for tonight was to pack the PEP
with people from all the closing schools after a pre-PEP rally, disrupt
the PEP for a time and then stage an elaborate walkout and march to the
alternate space at PS 20 where political allies would be waiting for s
series of speeches. Mulgrew will go in and try to lead the walkout by
using a megaphone.
They tried mighty hard to get all the other groups on board so the Tech
auditorium would be an empty shell when the PEP votes. They expected a
chunk of the press to be at PS 20. But the push back from the organized
groups and the schools themselves has caused the UFT some problems,
though we can assume that the UFT muscle may prevail, as the email just
sent out indicates.
There is an uprising in the making and many are staying.
Will the UFT get an empty auditorium, which would make the PEP very
happy --- see Afterburn below on what happened last year when the UFT
walked and Tweed heaved a sigh of relief.
Gotbaum sets up coalition
Over a month ago, Noah Gotbaum is an active parent on the CEC
in District 3 and a passionate defender of public schools called all
parties together to formulate a united plan for tonight and beyond. I
attended the first meeting with about 50 people, including 2 major
players, the UFT and CEJ (Coalition for Educational Justice) -- an
Annenberg Inst. backed parent/student organizing organization that has
focused on targeted schools and has demonstrated an ability to bring
people out --- they have been the only group to actually shut down a PEP
(Aug. 16, 2010 --- the first day we shot footage for the ITBWFS at that
event.) Noah has been tireless in racing from group to group to try to
hammer out something everyone can agree on. Believe me, it has not
always been easy and even at this late date there are still negotiations
going on. I'm still not sure if CEJ is going in --- they are marching
to Tech for a 5PM rally. UFT press conf is at 5:30.
The rise of ODOE as a force
About a month after OWS began, came ODOE, an amalgam of activists from
many teaching groups (GEM, ICE, NYCORE, Teachers Unite, TJC) along with
individuals from parent/community groups (CPE, ICOPE) came together
informally as Occupy DOE which has in its brief life since October shown
an amazing ability to organize and mobilize people for action --- the
first time a group outside the UFT has developed the muscle to actually
put a stop to a PEP. (ODOE meets every Sunday in an open and
The UFT tried to sway this coalition --- towards the walk-out or not go
in. But there was pushback, with ODOE taking a strong stand that "we
won't leave but use the people's mic to allow the schools to make their
statements, not to the PEP puppets by pleading, but to the public, which
will vote to keep the schools open.
The UFT has been very reluctant to actually try to stop the PEP tonight
--- or really at any time in the past for a number of reasons--- - see
Sam Anderson below. They will get hammered in the press and probably in
polls no matter what they do, though the latest shows that more people
trust the UFT than Bloomberg --- yes, even me.
The UFT has been sending out mixed messages. We reported (Walcott Turns Tail at Town Hall in Bronx A..) .
the UFT has been concerned about the new game in town -- Occupy DOE,
which insiders say concerns the UFT leadership because so many
opposition to Unity people are involved, with a bunch being behind
Saturday's State of the Union Conference.
Here is a missive about tonight's plans from Noah. There is amazing
organizing going on, a lot of it by some amazing new gen teachers that
would warm the cockles of your hearts.
Noah issues call to activists
Things are falling into place, thanks to the hard work of so many –
especially the folks at Occupy the DOE (ODOE), the New York Communities for
Change (NYCC), and the Coalition for Educational Justice (CEJ). The plan
for a well-organized, law abiding, democratic and community-based People’s
PEP inside of Brooklyn Tech has taken hold.
Programs explaining the People’s Mic process and People’s Pep agenda - as
well as voting cards and seating arrangements by school - are being prepared
for distribution. Please arrive by 5:30 – or earlier if you are helping out
- and look for these being handed out by ODOE and other members as you enter
the Brooklyn Tech Auditorium.
Support for our People’s Pep is increasing by the hour. There is unity in
the view that our efforts should not be a public venting of anger, but
rather a clear and sustained call for systemic change. It is also a strong
sign that despite Wadleigh’s middle school having been given a last minute
executioner’s reprieve by Lord Chancellor Walcott, the Wadleigh community
will be attending the People’s Pep en masse to protest the Success Charter
invasion which is still slated for their school, and to demand real changes
from one-man rule and supports for our public schools.
In answer to legitimate concerns of some regarding the risk of intervention
by DOE security officers, we can securely say that we have done, and are
doing, everything possible to minimize that risk. There will be no storming
of the stage, no blocking of the aisles, no chaos. Just a well-organized
demonstration of the People’s will and voice and, we hope, a mass movement
toward demanding the systemic change noted above. Such change should ensure
that our communities play a key decision-making role in the most important
decisions affecting OUR schools, OUR communities, OUR classrooms, and OUR
children including, at minimum, a change to the Mayoral Control law
requiring Parental/Community sign off on any contemplated school closings,
“truncations”, and charter co-locations.
As regards the UFT, we are grateful that they will be bringing many of us
As a reminder our overall plan/agenda is as follows:
and our fellow community members to the meeting from all corners of the
Sam Anderson from Coalition for Public Education (who plays a strong
role in our film) comments has a take on the UFT's refusal to
participate in a people's mic at the PEP, choosing instead to try to
rebrand it for their use --- in a school blocks away from the action:
Video: Janine Sopp on Using the People's mic
Unfortunately the Union leadership would rather find the mythical
middle ground so as to maintain ties with Billionaire Bloomberg and his
cohorts. Their move will draw a significant number of educators and
parents out of Brooklyn Tech tonight.
This reality means that we need a Plan B in place. May I suggest that
we have a flyer that says some variation of "The People's PEP Is POWER
from the 99%!" "The People's PEP is the foundation for a People's
Board of Education!" "Education Warriors don't walk away from a Fight
They Can Win!"
In addition, there should be at least 10 ODOE folk at their meeting
vocally raising the demand for a People's Board of Education instead of
trying to find a way to negotiate the nonnegotiables... trying to find
the middle ground when there is no middle ground.
I am confident that the vast majority of the parents and students will
stay at Brooklyn Tech and will participate in a seriously historical
moment of democracy-in-action. But, we should not let the UFT labor
aristocracy seize the media moment and obscure what happens at Brooklyn
In the past the UFT held disruptions and then walked out. They did that
at the January meeting after a Leo Casey shout-out "you walked out on
us on the evaluation issue, now we walk out on you."
Many of us were quite perturbed with their actions at the closing
schools PEP in Feb. 2011 when they held a great rally before the
meeting and then stopped the meeting dead in its tracks and could have
actually prevented a public vote but took the entire crowd out to walk
once around Brooklyn Tech before letting it dissipate (we used footage
from that in our film). To see the energy in that room --- and the
concern on the faces of the DOE and PEP puppets, followed by enormous
relief after the UFT pulled almost everyone out --- like Tweed had
managed to complete a tough bowel movement.
All it turned into was a demonstration of what the UFT could do ---
maybe a threat for the future. Fine. But if you have a gun how many
closed schools will it take to make you use it?
So this year, we have a new element --- the Occupy movement, in
particular the ODOE that has been meeting every Sunday at 60 Wall St
and attracting 50 people to each meeting. ODOE led a takeover at a
Walcott event on common core standards, forcing him to scurry upstairs (PEP Meeting OCCUPIED! A NEW DAY DAWNS!)
followed by actions at the PEP in December
Video: The PEP is trash
at Los Sures Feb. 7, 2012
For some other headlines on the blog, see below:· Joel Rose of the School of One returns...with a ruling that ignores the city's conflict of interest rules
· High school students tell Mayor Bloomberg why he should not close their schools
· A teacher's story: Why the DC Impact system Bloomberg wants NYC schools to adopt caused me to leave teaching
· Regents agree to give NY student data to limited corporation run by Gates and operated by Murdoch's Wireless Gen
Lindsey Christ NY1 report:
Have a good day
On Twitter: @normscott1
Education Notes Onlineednotesonline.blogspot.com/
GEM, Grassroots Education Movementgemnyc.org The Inconvenient Truth Behind Waiting for Supermanwww.waitingforsupermantruth.org
Education Editor, The Wavehttp://www.rockawave.com/
Norms's Robotics bloghttp://normsrobotics.blogspot.com/