Re: [NTO] Re: SPAM/Filtering
I don't get enough spam to havve a problem with it (max 4 to 5 spams a week)
but I'm fascinated by the topic of spam detection.
The rage seems to be baysian (probalistic) spam detection and I've been
using Popfile for some time. I also use it to classify my incoming email by
groups - eg. spam, check (unexpected but worth reading), mailing_lists_A
(the group that all the Notetab lists are in :-), mailing_lists_B (the ones
like theBat that I signed up for but rarely bother reading anymore),
newsletters_A, newsletters_B (same basic distinction as with the two
mailing_lists), acks_etc (stuff like "read this" responses when I've
requested a read reply, confirmations when joining lists).
Mailing_lists_A and _B and Newsletters_A and _B are done with magnets
(effectively whitelists) so they are 100% accurate though I still use a set
of OE_rules that I'd set up before starting to use Popfile to actually put
the incoming mail into folders to make reading it easier.
If however, you just want a straight spam / not_spam determination that can
be used as the basis for a dump_this decision I'd recommend having a look at
freeware K9 http://keir.net/k9.html .
Jody, this may not be appropriate for you if for whatever reason its
important NOT to actually download from your server. With the size of
harddisks (and especially if you've got highspeed access - ie. cable) I
think thats a much less important consideration than it used to be. AFAICS -
the important thing is that the person using the system be able to minimize
the time that has to be spent managing it, not that you prevent its physical
My impressions after brief use of K9 (actually I've got it set up so that
the traffic is ISP -> Popfile -> K9 -> emailClient (OE in my case)) is that
it is MUCH MUCH faster than Popfile in doing the classification (this may be
the difference between a C program and a Perl suite using a browser-based
UI) and that the GUI itself is VERY well designed for managing the email.
One nicety is that (if requested) it will put a [Spam-xx%] tag in the
subject line of anything it thinks has a 50% or higher probability of being
Spam. Until its fully trained, if you've set up filters in your email client
to move anything with subject containing "[Spam-" to a particular folder,
you can then sort by subject and check more carefully the stuff that's close
to the 50% mark and dump everything that has a 90% to 99% probability of
Regards ... Alec
---- Original Message ----
From: "Jody" <av1611@...>
Sent: Wednesday, September 03, 2003 20:30
Subject: [mla: Re: [NTO] Re: SPAM/Filtering
> Hi Alec and Julie,
> (Thanks Julie!)
> Bombarded daily here 200-350 it seems. Using eMail Remover v2.4
> to delete the junk at the server. I prefer it (v2.4) over 3.x and
> over Popcorn. In Popcorn you have to check the box - real small
> target area. In eRemover you can click anywhere on the line to
> select it. Ctrl+A works properly in eRemover also which is real
> handy to do with 200-350 or so messages to delete. I just do the
> Ctrl+A and un-select the messages to download. I do not think you
> can still download eMail Remover v2.4 anymore. You have to get
> the 3.x or above which has the nags. I suppose I could upload if
> anybody wants to check it out.
hrs: >> Another thing he (alec) mentioned, I'm not sure if nPoP does, is
>> messages from certain sources to pop up the MailCall headers window.Mailcall2 allows you to (if you wish) to essentially ignore which acct the
> Not sure I understand you here...
> If you have set nPOP to Auto-check every x minutes then it will check
> all accounts. However, accounts can be individually set to be exempt
> from a "Check All".
mail was sent to (that's how I like it)
Only one summary count total shown in the systray icon, but the icon changes
color if any mail came in that meets designated filter conditions.
For each filter you can designate which WAV file gets played. I recorded
messages so that I get:
"Personal mail for alec" (has the string "alec" in it)
"Mail for pattie" (it was sent to my wife's account - not much of this)
"Yahoo-bounce back" (To: contains @yahoogroups and From:is_my_account")
"Regular mail" anything not meeting one of the above three filter conditions
Only mail that meets "Personal mail for alec" condition has the flag set to
display a pop-list. When shown it lists ALL mail waiting on the server, with
the "Personal mail" sorted at the top.
Regards ... Alec
---- Original Message ----
From: "Greg Chapman" <greg@...>
Sent: Tuesday, September 16, 2003 12:20
Subject: [gla: RE: [NTO] Re: SPAM/Filtering