Re: [nslu2-linux] FAT, FAT32 etc
- Hi all,my $0.02 as a Windows user - any chance for NTFS support to be added as well please? No need to boot from the drive, but if Windows users can plug in their existing USB HDDs and not have to reformat then the device suddenly has a heck of a lot more usage for them (imho). Really seems to be a Linksys oversight on that point.regards,Craig----- Original Message -----From: Jason CooperSent: Friday, August 20, 2004 6:02 AMSubject: Re: [nslu2-linux] FAT, FAT32 etcMatt McNeill (matt_mcneill@...) scribbled:
> One of the major disadvantages in the reviews for this item (Tom's
> Hardware) is that to attach your USB drive it requires reformatting.
> It's kinda permanent really if you have one of the ubiquitous Win32
> machines. Furthermore, if like me, you have already got 100Gb+ on your
> Maxtor 250, this device is a waste of time unless you are prepared to
> shell out for another drive.
> Now, if I remember rightly from my days of playing around with Linux
> on dual boot machines, it is possible for linux to mount FAT/FAT32
> So, if you will excuse my ignorance, what are the hurdles that face
> the idea of booting from a FAT/FAT32 mount rather than an ext3 linux
Two scenarios (I have the parts for the serial converter on my desk, so
forgive the fact that I am not too far along yet :)
1.) The stock kernel allows modules
Get the stock kernel source and create the vfat, etc modules.
create a new initrd image with the modules included.
mod some scripts to allow mounting the drive w/o formatting.
2.) No module support in stock kernel
Get the stock kernel sources, compile a new kernel w/ vfat
Replace the kernel with the new one.
modify scripts etc...
> Or even simply mounting a FAT/FAT32 drive to share it as normal as a
> second drive having booted from a ext3 primary drive?
Getting any linux kernel to view and use a windows partition is easy (no
booting from it), getting the Linksys generated apps to work with it is
another matter. Which is why my approach is to not even bother with the
provided apps other than what is necessary in the kernel to see the
- Craig Procter (craigwp@...) scribbled:
> Hi all,Or a bad marketing attempt at lock-in... :)
> my $0.02 as a Windows user - any chance for NTFS support to be added as well
> please? No need to boot from the drive, but if Windows users can plug in
> their existing USB HDDs and not have to reformat then the device suddenly
> has a heck of a lot more usage for them (imho). Really seems to be a
> Linksys oversight on that point.
Just looked at 126.96.36.199 kernel, NTFS read support is fine. However,
write support is restricted, but safe. By restricted, you can write to
files that already exist, as long as the new data is exactly the same
length. I read this as "it ain't ready" :( Sorry.