Re: Picture vs still graphic
- Hi Kelvin & group,
I'm working on determining which item classes our systems must use (and when).
Does your explanation of picture vs still graphic below translates to "video vs animated graphic" ?
That is, a video would be "an animated visual representation of a physical object, person or scene", which includes the result of actual video shootings but also some computer generated 3D sequences or animated artist drawings. And an animated graphic would be for "an animated visual representation with symbolic content (e.g. animated chart, diagram, logo, map etc.)" ?
--- In email@example.com, Kelvin Holland <kholland@...> wrote:
> HI Philippe,
> The itemClass property allows the provider to identify the intended use
> of the content, rather than a description of the format. Traditionally,
> news organisations have managed and used pictures (photographic images)
> in a different way to graphic art. These notions persist today and are
> still quite useful: you see many many web pages where a text, chart and
> picture (photo) are placed in specific consistent positions.
> The dictionary says a picture is a visual representation of a physical
> object, person or scene. In news, most of the time this means a
> photograph. Another example could be an artist's drawing. These can be
> used to depict a scene that is inaccessible to photographers, for
> example courtrooms in some countries..
> A graphic is a symbolic representation, often with text labels. for
> example a map, company logo, or a chart.
> If you draw a chart illustrating "EU five-year growth forecast" in
> Photoshop and save it in png format, it is still a graphic.
> A definition that aims to be precise might not be very useful, because
> the terms are loose and are sometimes interpreted differently, but
> without causing any major problems.
> On 28/12/2011 10:21, Philippe Mougin wrote:
> > Hi,
> > NewsML-G2 differentiates picture and still graphic content. One
> > difference is that their news item nature are different concept URIs.
> > Another difference is that they don't have the same default dimension
> > units.
> > But what content should be considered "picture" and what content
> > should be considered "still graphic" ? For example, if I draw some
> > graphic in Photoshop and save it in PNG format, is it a "picture" or a
> > "still graphic", and why?
> > Is there a comprehensive definition of item nature somewhere ?
> > Thanks,
> > Philippe