Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Debate Revisited

Expand Messages
  • Andre Cramblit
    Sensitive issue of race stirred again Published: June 5, 2003 By Laura Brown Triplicate staff writer Del Norte High School s abandoned mascot is stirring up
    Message 1 of 1 , Jun 5, 2003
    • 0 Attachment
      Sensitive issue of race stirred again

      Published: June 5, 2003

      By Laura Brown

      Triplicate staff writer

      Del Norte High School's abandoned mascot is stirring up controversy again.

      This time, an image resembling one that caused tension within the school
      system five years ago caught some students and faculty off guard when it
      appeared in a newly released yearbook.

      Five students in the Native American Club found the outdated line drawing a
      stereotypical portrayal of tribal people and voiced their complaints to the

      The exaggerated Hollywood-style interpretation depicts a scantily clad
      muscular Plains Indian, arms crossed over chest, wearing an eagle-feather

      "It was shocking that the old mascot was being used," said Loren Bommelyn,
      club advisor.

      Indian mascots are still commonplace around the country, and in California,
      more than 120 schools continue to use them.

      The California State Assembly will vote on AB 858, the California Racial
      Mascots Act today. The legislation is geared toward removing racially
      discriminatory school and team mascots.

      "Native Americans are the only group of living people used as mascots,"
      said Andre Cramblit, operations director of Northern California Indian
      Development Council.

      Del Norte High School Principal Jan Moorehouse said the recent yearbook
      issue has been resolved. After meeting with the offended students,
      Moorehouse agreed to reimburse them the $60 they paid for the annuals.

      Moorehouse said the subject is still a painful one for students and staff
      who remember the controversy over Del Norte High School's wooden mascot,
      which was taken down in the late 1990s. The figure, blackened by fire, is
      now housed at the historical society.

      The mascot was at the center of an emotional debate that lasted nine
      months. A committee decided the icon, which had been in place for at least
      20 years, could be considered disrespectful to people and their religion.

      While the redwood carving was eventually removed from the school, the name
      ‘Warriors' remained but is no longer tied to American Indians.

      Carl Woods, who is serving in his second year as yearbook advisor, said
      deadlines and a limited supply of photographs meant that the student staff
      relied heavily on clip art. It was an innocent mistake made by a student
      struggling to get the yearbook ready for print in less than three months,
      said Woods.

      Woods said he contacted Bommelyn by phone beforehand, telling him of the
      yearbook staff's intention to run the pen-and-ink drawing.

      "I wasn't concerned about using it, because I figured he would have
      contacted me if he had any problems," said Woods.

      Bommelyn said he doesn't recall being told about the use of the Plains
      Indian caricature. He says he remembers telling Woods of some Tolowa
      basketry patterns that would make suitable art. He said he never saw the
      images used until yearbooks were being passed around by students in the

      Bommelyn said he is satisfied with the way the administration handled the

      In a statement, Moorehouse compares this year's grievances with those from
      students who find their name misspelled or the placement of an embarrassing
      photo caption.

      "In spite of best efforts, not everyone is pleased with the product built
      by the yearbook staff of any school in any year," reads a statement from

      Moorehouse suggested including a brief history of the mascot controversy
      within student handbooks each year to remind them of this delicate issue.

      Native American children make up 13 percent of the school system in Del
      Norte County.

      Jim McQuillen, head of the American Indian Education Program and principal
      of Margaret Keating School, says this is a time of transition, and
      education is the key to moving beyond biased views.

      "I think we all need ongoing education of those that are culturally
      different, and that includes American Indians," he said. "There continues
      to be a need for education, not just for students, but staff, too.

      This August, a three-day workshop, "Local Connections," will be conducted
      for teachers. The course will bring to light sensitive issues for local
      tribes, and includes a visit to ancient village sites.

      Natives go to:
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.