Re: [mythsoc] Re: Shelf Esteem
- At 04:00 AM 11/28/2001 , Trudy wrote:
> Didn't Tolkien dislike the three-volume division more, or do IOne physical volume per book was not an option presented to him. Had it
> recall that incorrectly?>>
> More than dividing LotR into six volumes(one volume per book).
been, he (and his publishers) could well have disliked it for making it
just too many volumes, and too much of a hassle to buy if published
separately at different times, as the original 3-volume edition was. I
view the new 7-volume edition as a gimmick, if a well-produced one, and
note that I've seen it offered only as a set.
Tolkien's dislike of the 3-volume division was based on concern that people
would think he'd written 3 books instead of one, as well as on the
artificial association of the constituent books - in particular, Books 3
and 4 seemed disassociated to him.
What would you think of a 2-volume edition: Books 1-3 and 4-6?