- This all seems silly to me. There just is no shortage of novels that are
fully Genre, fully Literature and deservedly popular. We could spend hours
Lord of the Rings, The Dispossessed, Lord or Light, City in the Stars, That
Hideous Strength, Neuromancer, Dune, Alice in Wonderland...
If this work make Academia nervous... oh well. The Impressionist painters
made Academia a lot more upset than Genre fiction.
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Tuesday, October 24, 2000 12:17 AM
Subject: [mythsoc] Genre Literature
> This all seems silly to me. There just is no shortage of novels that are
> fully Genre, fully Literature and deservedly popular.
> If this work make Academia nervous... oh well. The Impressionist painters
> made Academia a lot more upset than Genre fiction.
> - Stephen
Perhaps we're lucky to have been mostly excluded from "literature," and so
escape the hopelessness that seems to run rampant there. (After all, the
Impressionists had to hold their own showings, since they weren't allowed
into the Academy displays.) It's interesting that much of the genre fiction
that has been "allowed" into literature has some of this same negative feel:
Brave New World, 1984...
I'm not in the Academia of English study (I work in the medical school, not
the humanities division), but I do have two sisters who have tried to
convert me to "serious" reading, which seems to mean novels that see the
world and humanity as causes for despair. Me, I like a little hope--and,
you know, the funny thing is, I believe the real world *is* a place of hope
and humanity really *does* aspire to higher things. It's the doomsayers
that seem out-of-touch with reality. Makes you feel kind of sorry for them,
Recently, my sisters have "lightened up" a little in their reading. One
happened to read some of Le Guin's essays (the book being asked about on
this list recently) and asked me, almost humbly, if I could recommend any of
her fiction--which, of course, I was happy to do. Seemed kind of like a
repayment--if this sister hadn't left her abandoned volumes of The Lord of
the Rings lying around the house for me to pick up, who knows where I would