Re: [mythsoc] Re: Astarte and Mary
- Hee hee -- I suppose that's one way! We honestly used it more as a guide to literary criticism -- how are people of this school of thought interpreting myths? -- which is how we applied the Jung, Barfield, and Hamlet's Mill texts as well. That said, the maiden-mother-crone and year king as husband-child sacrifice themes do seem to appear all over the place, whether in the old texts or in modern fantasy novels with a mythic backdrop, so whether Graves was inventing things wholesale or picking up on bits that people have continued to recycle, it make sense for him to belong in the canon of people to read when you're reading about how other people read myth.
Along the lines of "danger here, if you see this it's bollocks all the
way down?" sort of warning sign? :)And honestly, I think that's a study (how people read myth) that's almost as interesting as studying mythology itself. I spent some time reading one of the Grimm brother's (Jacob, I think) guide to Teutonic mythology, and his interpretations were fascinating -- and different than I'd seen elsewhere -- as were the things he expected his readers to just be familiar with. (He used something like four languages in the English-language translation I read, none of which I was fluent in.) Reading books on folklore compiled in the late 1800s or early 1900s has this pro-colonial angle, where the more modern books I've read tend to try to more accurately capture the pre-colonized viewpoint. All of this is a tangent, of course, but I include it here because The White Goddess seems to be a text that some modern groups have utilized wholesale, so being familiar with it offers a way to understand where the "Celtic Tree Zodiac" quizzes on facebook come from. :) I remember enjoying reading it at the time, as well, so there's that as well!-Alana--
Alana Joli Abbott, Freelance Writer and Editor (http://www.virgilandbeatrice.com)Author of Into the Reach and Departure http://tinyurl.com/aja-ebooksRegaining Home is Kickstarted! http://tinyurl.com/kickstartregaininghomeAuthor of interactive novel Choice of Kung Fu http://tinyurl.com/aja-cogContributor to Haunted: 11 Tales of Ghostly Horror http://tinyurl.com/haunted-aja--For updates on my writings, join my mailing list at http://groups.google.com/group/alanajoliabbottfans
- On Mon, Jun 17, 2013 at 02:36:10PM -0700, John Rateliff wrote:
> And it's just as interesting to see what current thinking amongFor that matter, there's Michael Witzel's _The Origins of the World's
> the historians and archeologists and scientist is on some of these
> same issues -- e.g., the recent Cunliffe and Koch volume CELTIC
> FROM THE WEST, which I only learned about at this year's Kalamazoo,
> challenges a lot of what I'd been taught about the origins of the
> Celts and turns it on its head.
Mythologies_, which is grand synthesis on an almost unbelievable
scale (myths, linguistics, genetics -- all leading back to reconstructing
common mythological structures and heading back into common elements
among groups that have been separated since the colonization of
Australia...) Just recently out, and very interesting.
Courage is a virtue. It does not follow that all
courageous acts are in the service of virtuous ends.