- I agree about John R. also--eminently sane critic. I ve not yet received my copy of *Fall of Arthur* yet, but I ve read the heroic alliterative verse of hisMessage 1 of 25 , May 26, 2013View SourceI agree about John R. also--eminently sane critic. I've not yet received my copy of Fall of Arthur yet, but I've read the heroic alliterative verse of his reimagined lays for Sigurd and Gudrun. Comparing them to Williams's Arthurian poetry is almost like comparing apples and oranges, they're such different colors and tastes. But of course, literary palates often prefer one to the other.And the 1975 Tolkien recordings are priceless: http://www.discogs.com/JRR-Tolkien-Reads-And-Sings-His-The-Lord-Of-The-Rings-The-Two-Towers-Return-Of-The-King/release/704586Cheers,TravisOn Sun, May 26, 2013 at 2:15 AM, Mike Foster <mafoster@...> wrote:John Rateliff is (as usual) right. This work will be honored as one of Tolkien’s finest; it begs to be read aloud, loud aloud.In some of the best passages, one hears JRRTreading “The Ride of the Rohirrim” in George Sayer’s recordings.Because of the death of a longtime (since 1961) friend, visits of commiseration, writings eulogics, hosting visitors &c., I am only as far as canto 5. I’m eschewing all the notes and commentary so far.Moreover, Far Westfarthing smial is reading Charles Williams’ The Place of the Lion for our May 31 meeting. I’m up to Ch. 5.I read Tolkien, then I read Williams.Tolkien is better.MikeJohn
Yesterday thanks to a train ride to and from Cardiff to meet my Postgraduate Research supervior (Dr. Dimitra Fimi) on the progress of my Tolkien thesis I had the chance to do a complete first read of The Fall of Arthur as I travelled through 'the walls of Wales.'
Like you John I was completly blown away by Tolkien's plans (sadly not completed) to link the poem to his mythology and the Lost Literature of Faerie. The idea of linking Arthur (and Lancelot!) to Earende/Wingelotl and going into the West is quite interesting (love how Tolkien completely dismisses the Glastonbery element). I kept thinking of the hermit they visit before going to the west as Cirdan the Shipwright at the Grey Havens! Also the occurance of the name Avallone in the mythology as an alternative name for Tol-Eressea around the time Tolkien was working on Fall of Arthur is quite interesting and needs more investigation (I also wonder if and how this might link to the older names Arvalin (a later name for Habbanan) as in 'the wide plains of Arvalin (Lost Tales 1, p.70) also listed in the Qenya Lexicon and if this was also an Arthurian inspired early idea - more grist for the thesis!
The actual poem is brilliant and I find it interesting that Tolkien focuses so much on the character of Mordred (who has always been a very shadowy character - except in the musical Camelot where he gets to sing 'The Seven Deadly Virtues. Tolkien's Mordred seems to have a lot of the dark lord about him - he watches from towers and he goes to the East to lead an army against Arthur. On my second read I will pay more attention to this.
A book that was worth the wait and the commentary Christopher gives linking the poem to both the Arthurian tradition and the the ermeging mythology is invaluable.
Second read to come this weekend!
On May 24, 2013, at 07:39 AM, John Rateliff <sacnoth@...> wrote:
So, anybody else read THE FALL OF ARTHUR yet?
Biggest surprise for me was the revelation that in it Tolkien linked up the Arthurian story to his legendarium.
That, and his giving us in Guinevere what I think is his most negative portrayal of a female character.
Not to mention that now we'll have to qualify statements about his depiction of the Angles and Saxons in his work by taking into account their treatment here -- at one point he has King Arthur playing pretty much the role the Romans play in Wm Morris's HOUSE OF THE WOLFINGS, wh. I wdn't have expected.
Plus, of course, the fact that just judged as poetry there are some memorable lines (the best of which, describing Guinevere, was quoted long ago by Carpenter: "fair as fay-woman and fell-minded, in the world walking for the woe of men").
I think this one's going to take a while for people to absorb, but once they do that it'll be judged a major work. Guess we'll see. I know I'm already looking forward to leisurely re-reading it, more slowly this time.
- Hello, The comments here make me hope my own copy of the book will arrive soon. However, I ve just come across a small piece of information. As pointed out byMessage 2 of 25 , May 30, 2013View SourceHello,
The comments here make me hope my own copy of the book will arrive soon.
However, I've just come across a small piece of information. As pointed out by Julien Mansencal, it seems the book cover of _The Fall of Arthur_ is inspired by the 13th century grave of a knight of Palays (from South-West France), now located in the Musée des Augustins in Toulouse, my hometown.
Of course, I'm planning to have a look it's been a long time I haven't visited this museum. Any visiting Tolkiendil is free to join!
--- In email@example.com, Alana Joli Abbott <alanajoli@...> wrote:
> > As Travis says, the Eerdmans edition is probably your best bet, via
> > bookfinder.com or abebooks.com. This reprints the second and third of
> > Williams' Arthurian books, TALIESSIN THROUGH LOGRES (1938) and THE REGION
> > OF THE SUMMER STARS (1944), as well as the unfinished prose history/summary
> > of the Arthurian legend (THE FIGURE OF ARTHUR) Wms was working on when he
> > died and CSL's extensive commentary on Wms' cycle (WILLIAMS AND THE
> > ARTHURIAD), both of which had been published under the title ARTHURIAN
> > TORSO (1948).
> John, thanks for this and the further detailed comments! Very informative,
> and I'll definitely give a try to hunting them down. (After I've finished
> doing the jury reading for the MFAs of course!)
> Alana Joli Abbott, Freelance Writer and Editor (
> Author of *Into the Reach* and *Departure *http://tinyurl.com/aja-ebooks
> *Regaining Home *is Kickstarted!* *http://tinyurl.com/kickstartregaininghome
> Author of interactive novel *Choice of Kung Fu* http://tinyurl.com/aja-cog
> Contributor to *Haunted: 11 Tales of Ghostly Horror*
> For updates on my writings, join my mailing list at