Re: [mythsoc] Having seen THE HOBBIT...
- Mich - I don't want to comment on just how Jackson presents this sequence
in this film because that really would be a spoiler for people who have
not seen it yet.
As for the differences in how the scene is show in the LOTR films and
here, that's just the nature of doing a prequel, I suppose. The director
has to restage something.
> Hi I have not as of yet seen the film but I am going to see it tomorrow
> when it comes out hear in Canada. with this in mind though I have been
> reading some reviews in fact all of the reviews that have been posted to
> this list thanks guys. I am just wondering one thing you say that
> Jackson's handling of the crucial moment in the story the finding of the
> ring was bumbled and miss handled by Jackson and co. I have red in another
> review that it shows golem loosing the ring and the ring tumbling down a
> rock facewith a big clanging sound where Bilbo then again picks it up.
> that jmo would be bumbling in deed since in the book this didn't happen.
> but like you pointed out the book is mostly written from Bilbo's
> perspective. I also wanted to ask didn't we see how Bilbo found the ring
> in flotr? since that seen I am thinking of in the review sounds similar to
> the seen in flashback in flotr. as for the score I found the music in
> flotr and all the lotr films very nice and so am looking forward to
> hearing the music in The Hobbit. also as far as 2 d vs 3d 42 fps etc as
> some one who is blind it doesn't madder to me one bit weather the movie is
> in 3d 42fps or 2d since the sound will not be effected. I know that on
> another list people in the uk who are blind were complaining that after
> Thursday they were only going to be showing the 3d version with the 42 fps
> and that they didn't think they needed to be charged as much since they
> would only be able to hear the movie and so there for would not be able to
> get the full effect of 3d or 42 fps anyways. from Mich.