Re: [mythsoc] Quellenforschung
- Margaret Dean <margdean@...> wrote:
>Joe Christopher wrote:Besides, they're characters of no importance, they're not described as son and father (I'm not going to bother to check HoME to see if there's any additional info there), and they are described as servants of Barahir's house rather than kings. There's no relationship between the mythologies here and no evidence of one. This isn't Quellenforschung, this is folk etymology, creating allusions by the process of what a word happens to sound like to the reader. This is how we get claims that Nazgul are Nazis.
>> I wonder if "Arthad and Urthel" (_Silmarillion_ p. 155) were inspired by
>> (King) Arthur and Uther (Pendragon)?
>I dunno. The context isn't very Arthurian, more like Robin Hood.