Re: Jackson movies as film art
- --- In firstname.lastname@example.org, "dbltall42" <dbltall@...> wrote:
>This is one of the few scenes that I found incredibly powerful. Yes, I
> ...the scene with Denethor's poor table manners intercut with
> Faramir falling swoopily...
knew I was being manipulated but it seemed "appropriate" to me,
somehow, a kind of shorthand to show us Faramir's nobility and how far
Denethor had fallen, while Pippin (of all people) sings this
beautiful, stark *a capella* song...
> It is probably the case that different people appreciate differentYup. And that's a good thing, imho.
> things in movies, just as we do in books.
-- Lynn --