5559Re: [mythsoc] Re: David's list of fictionalized Lewises and Tolkiens
- Mar 11, 2002In a message dated 3/11/2002 9:24:20 AM Pacific Standard Time,
> I didn't think it was a very good story, even on its own terms.No, nor did I. But I've read various posts and reviews by a lot of people
really like it, so I don't think Dozois' simply filling space -- different
folks can have different taste, after all!
I think you're right that Egan didn't do justice to Lewis' apologetics; what
drove me nuts about the story was that it depicted Lewis as closed-minded,
humorless and fearful -- which is the image that too many non-Christians have
of Christians. The story depicts his faith as confining, rather than
freeing. If I read one more SF story where people of faith are depicted as
dunderheads, I'll scream *very* completely.
Not, of course, that there aren't many honorable exceptions.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>