5065Re: [mythsoc] Carpenter's biography
- Feb 6, 2002thanks for your answer.
I do agree : Carpenter's biography is the best, even if it is sometimes too exclusively factual ; I do not like Pearce's, nor Grotta's, not to speak of Coren's...
The bibliography of Tolkien's writings has been updated and corrected in
various reprintings. I believe the text remains unchanged, though a few
factual errors - mostly about the details of the composition of Tolkien's
works - have been uncovered in the course of work on the "History of
Carpenter's biography remains remarkably accurate and very insightful, far
superior to any other biographies of Tolkien.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>