Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

25232Re: Beowulf translation

Expand Messages
  • ernestsdavis
    Mar 29, 2014
    • 0 Attachment

      NB column by T.E.L (Toby Lichtig? Thea Lenarduzzi?) on back page of TLS (March 28) anticipates the Tolkien translation. Doesn't seem to be online yet, except to subscribers. Excerpt:

      News that Tolkien's translation of Beowulf is to be published for the first time this spring has aroused great interest from Tolkien academics and enthusiasts. The translation, completed in 1926 had been known about for many years, but the decision to release it was only taken recently. The author himself "seems never to have considered its publication" commented Christopher Tolkien.

      How, then, might the ghost of Tolkien Senior greet the decision? One clue as to his opinion can be found in a piece he wrote for TLS in 1923. The review was of Hali Meidenhad: A alliterative prose homily of the thirteenth century in an edition by the founder of the Early English Text Society, F.J. Furnivall (1825-1910).

      The thirty-one year old Tolkien found it "much to be regretted that before his death Dr. Furnivall did not, apparently, complete his work, which is here published without alteration as he left it." Tolkien's main gripe was with a lack of editorial interference: "It may be doubted whether, even though it has been done out of great respect for a great name, the best service has been rendered to that name, or to English scholarship, by publishing work that might have been revised and supplemented."

      Since Tolkien's death forty years ago, Christopher Tolkien has established an excellent reputation as an editor of his father's works, and, whatever the state of the original translation, we can expect the best service. The edition will incorporate a previously unpublished story "Sellic Spell" and the series of lectures Tolkien gave about Beowulf at Oxford University in the 1930's, including "Beowulf: The monster and the critics" an influential piece of criticism that helped to rescue the poem's reputation as a valuable literary work in its own right rather than an ill-fitting mishmash of legends useful largely as a historical document. Reviewing R.W. Chamber's study of the poem in the TLS in 1922, Prof. Bruce Dickins had found it necessary to begin with an apologia: "Beowulf, with all its shortcomings in fable, structure, and characterization ..." That kind of caveat was de rigeuer. Dickins approved of Chambers's (largely historical) treatment, but admitted that "in a field so thoroughly worked, there is not perhaps much room for originality." He hadn't reckoned with the intervention of J.R.R. Tolkien.

      Beowulf: A translation and commentary together  with "Sellic Spell" will be available from HarperCollins for L20 from May 22. It will be reviewed in a forthcoming edition of the TLS.

    • Show all 24 messages in this topic