24050Re: [mythsoc] Fw: "The J.R.R. Tolkien Companion & Guide: Chronology: 1"
- Jan 17, 2013A joke with added typo, sadly. Sigh. lost=lot. Obviously.----- Original Message -----From: John DavisSent: Thursday, January 17, 2013 3:10 PMSubject: Re: [mythsoc] Fw: "The J.R.R. Tolkien Companion & Guide: Chronology: 1"Peter Jackson has gotten a lost of unjustified criticism...Except for occasional moments where he used Tolkien's own words, Jackson's films shouldn't be thought of as the 'actual' representation of the secondary world, but as Jackson's own artistic responses to Tolkien's books.Disclaimer: that was a joke. A joke, I tell you. Insert smiley faces and multiple exclamation marks if necessary. It absolutely wasn't intended to rekindle the tired old debate.----- Original Message -----From: David BratmanSent: Thursday, January 17, 2013 6:54 AMSubject: Re: [mythsoc] Fw: "The J.R.R. Tolkien Companion & Guide: Chronology: 1"
"John Rateliff" sacnoth@...> wrote:
>I'm sorry to say Wm Elvin's singing is no better than I remembered.
Tolkien liked his name, but he's not a very good singer: stiff and
inexpressive. Every other performance of the cycle I've heard (all live; I
don't know of any other recordings) I've liked better.
>Somehow I can't suspend my disbelief that Sam found a piano in Cirith Ungol
>to accompany himself for "In Western Lands".
Swann has gotten a lot of unjustified criticism for this. Except for
"Namarie", for which he used Tolkien's own melody, Swann's songs shouldn't
be thought of as the "actual" music of the secondary world, but as Swann's
own artistic responses to Tolkien's poetry, in the manner of art songs by
the likes of Schubert on down.
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>