19344Re: [mythsoc] Mystical Realms . . .
- Jan 10, 2008Hi Carl
Afraid I'll have to wait to respond until I have a chance to find and
read CSL's piece, or else we'll drift entirely off-topic.
On Jan 10, 2008, at 5:52 AM, Carl F. Hostetter wrote:
> I didn't say that governments "arose" for this purpose (though many
> did, at least in part). I said this _is_ (pretty much) the purpose of
> government: present tense, and in the specific context of this
> discussion concerning CSL and Aquinas. It has certainly been the
> primary purpose of esp. democratic governments. Tolkien also saw it as
> a primary purpose of (legitimate) monarchies.
> Is that all Jesus was? Is that all Peter was doing here? Peter was
> earlier, and more forcefully, rebuked for simply urging Jesus not to
> see through his mission of dying for our sins. ("Get thee behind me,
> Satan!") Isn't that what Peter was doing here, too?
> Have you read Revelations? In light of which, it is well to remember
> that Jesus also said "I come not to bring peace, but to bring a
> sword". Now, one can argue that Jesus was not speaking of a literal
> sword (I would make the same argument) but no matter how you interpret
> it, it is clear that Jesus's message was not simply one of "peace".
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>