19341Re: [mythsoc] Mystical Realms . . .
- Jan 9, 2008On Jan 9, 2008, at 7:39 PM, John D Rateliff wrote:
> Um, do I really need to point out that the whole 'turn the otherDo you really think _that_ is either CSL's or Aquinas's claim? (I.e.,
> cheek' thing was a direct instruction from Jesus Christ himself? And
> that when Peter tried to meet force with force, Christ told him to
> knock it off in no uncertain terms? CSL and Aquinas may win some over
> by claiming that Jesus didn't really know what he was talking about
that "Jesus didn't really know what he was talking about"?) Or could
it perhaps be that CSL and Aquinas don't think that what is right and
admirable when chosen as a personal response to personal threat, is
either right or admirable when it comes to defending _others_ from
threats? (Which, you know, is pretty much the _purpose_ of
government.) In other words, do you think Jesus enjoins us not to
defend others? If so, do you think that Jesus meant that governments
should not defend their citizens?
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>