19223Re: [mythsoc] Lucy, Galadriel, and Temptation
- Dec 7 5:34 PMOn Dec 7, 2007, at 8:00 AM, Jason Fisher wrote:
>> So, I assume that for _some_ people and in _some_ circumstances,Maybe it's simpler than that. If people wish upon a star, in a
>> the "beauty" spell might be used for good.
> Can you actually think of such a scenario? Perhaps it's a limit to
> my imagination, but I can't.
magical world that star has to be able to grant their wish, right?
And 'fairest in the land' is a pretty standard one. So it's not
surprising an ex-star would know how to do that.
That said, the whole thing of letting Lucy misuse the spellbook
and only intervening when she thinks about doing so again has always
been one of my least favorite scenes in the book. I can try to
rationalize Aslan's behavior, but in the end it always comes across
as arbitrary to me. One of the reasons I can read the books as
fantasy but not as allegory.
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>