15932Re: [mythsoc] CSL on live-action Aslan: "Blasphemy"
- Dec 3, 2005At 02:23 PM 12/3/2005 -0500, Hugh Davis wrote:
>The letter (on http://www.nthposition.com/blasphemyinnarnia.php) saysAnd that is what the news article originally quoted by Patrick Wynne (based
>Magician's Nephew in brackets, so I had that in my head as the one adapted.
on the letter, presumably) says too, which I didn't notice when I wrote
about the 1959 LWW.
But Hooper's Companion, my source, is very clear that it was LWW. He gives
a cast list, and I do not recall Peter, Susan, Edmund, Lucy, and Mr Tumnus
appearing in The Magician's Nephew.
I suspect what happened is this: whoever added the bracketed reference to
MN to the letter had registered that the book dramatized was the first of
the Chronicles, and then went to look at a current copy and found that MN
was the "first"!!!
Yet another example of the toxicity of the change of ordering.
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>